When to take Whey

LogreBeast · 06-25-2001, 01:05 AM

I've read so many different things about this. You are supposed to wait an hour after you work out to eat. But then you are supposed to consume the shakes right after you work out. What is the best to do? What I am trying right now is this. (and i'm trying to get lean, not big, so please tell me if this is a bad idea.) I wake up. Make a shake that contains 20 grams of protein. I go to school for 2 hrs, then go work out for an hour. It takes a good 30 minutes to get home. Right when i get home i have a shake that contains 40 grams of protein, then i wait an hour and have a regular meal. I eat very healthy for the rest of the day. First of all, is this ok to do? They are both Whey Protein Shakes. And second will this make me lean. I don't want to gain weight because i'm already a big guy with a large build. Thanks for any help you can give me.

w8lifter · 06-25-2001, 04:28 AM

I think you need some serious food in the morning there. Are you not hungry? I'd be starving! Food isn't a bad thing. Eating a good breakfast will ensure that you make healthier food choices later in the day because you won't be starving.

As for eating after working out, it's common practice to drink a liquid shake (or smoothie) right after working out because liquid form is digested the fasted. Personally, if I have time, I take a shake right after, then cook a meal of protein and carbs and eat that 30-45 minutes later. But, sometimes I just have the meal. In your case, since you haven't had food for so long, I'd be eating a good meal.

You don't say what type of workout you're doing...cardio or weights. If you're doing weights after only having a shake 2 hours earlier, you may get a better workout (lift heavier, last longer) if you eat a decent breaky w/ some complex carbs. Oats w/ a scoop of protein added will take you further than just the shake alone. Anyway, jmo

**Robert D.** · 06-25-2001, 07:27 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by LogreBeast:
I've read so many different things about this. You are supposed to wait an hour after you work out to eat. But then you are supposed to consume the shakes right after you work out.
A protein shake is easily digested and utilized. It takes the body longer to break down food and utilize the protein.

What is the best to do? What I am trying right now is this. (and i'm trying to get lean, not big, so please tell me if this is a bad idea.) I wake up. Make a shake that contains 20 grams of protein.
I would suggest a more complete breakfast, maybe throw in some carbs. How about a shake and a bowl of cereal.

I go to school for 2 hrs, then go work out for an hour. It takes a good 30 minutes to get home. Right when i get home i have a shake that contains 40 grams of protein, then i wait an hour and have a regular meal.
That is fine

I eat very healthy for the rest of the day. First of all, is this ok to do? They are both Whey Protein Shakes. And second will this make me lean.
There are other variable to consider to get lean. The main thing is how many calories you're consuming each day.

I don't want to gain weight because i'm already a big guy with a large build. Thanks for any help you can give me.
I think we could help you more if you gave us more details. Such as your stats, goals, sample diet, work-out you're using, etc.

------------------
Just because the majority believes it, does not make it true!

LogreBeast · 06-25-2001, 10:30 AM

Sorry for the lack of details. I am a 6'8" guy.I'm 19. I used to weigh 280 lbs, i'm now down to 245 which is my ideal weight. I was never obese, i am just a very big guy. My goal is to get lean. About like Edward Norton in American Histroy X (my favorite movie). The shake is a meal replacement that i take. it has 26 grams of carbs in it. It is a meal replacement shake. I'm not hungry at all. I found out today that the shake also contains some Casein Protein as well as egg protein and more. It is a very good shake. It's the B-Fit RX shake from Bally's. In the morning i take the Lite Version, which contains the 20 grams. I work out on the weights. I don't do heavy lifting. I do high volume. Like lower weight. A mid way amount of reps, but more sets. Like on bench i do about 5 sets of 10 or 12. I work out about 5 or 6 days a week. I need more cardio. During the regular year, i play a lot of basketball. So that won't be a problem. But for now i do occasional swimming. And even less occasional running. After i have the 2nd shake, my meals consist of things like a chicken sandwich with mustard a lot of lettuce and and lean chicken that has about 20 grams of protein and 3 grams of fat or so. Then i have another sandwich later on. about 4 hrs later. And the end of the night i have a small amount of Tuna to keep my stomach busy at night. Sometimes during the day i have a smoothie that i make of my own. It only contains natural fruits that i buy at the store. I put strawberries, grapes, and either one or two bananas. Thanks for all the help guys. I really appreciate the input.

06-25-2001, 01:05 AM	#1
LogreBeast Registered User Join Date: Jun 2001 Location: Austin, TX, 78705 Posts: 5	When to take Whey I've read so many different things about this. You are supposed to wait an hour after you work out to eat. But then you are supposed to consume the shakes right after you work out. What is the best to do? What I am trying right now is this. (and i'm trying to get lean, not big, so please tell me if this is a bad idea.) I wake up. Make a shake that contains 20 grams of protein. I go to school for 2 hrs, then go work out for an hour. It takes a good 30 minutes to get home. Right when i get home i have a shake that contains 40 grams of protein, then i wait an hour and have a regular meal. I eat very healthy for the rest of the day. First of all, is this ok to do? They are both Whey Protein Shakes. And second will this make me lean. I don't want to gain weight because i'm already a big guy with a large build. Thanks for any help you can give me.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
New All The Whey Forum!	Spaceman Spiff	Diet & Nutrition	1	06-25-2007 09:02 PM
Why not Chicken breast and PB for Dinner?	brukabay	Diet & Nutrition	24	05-17-2007 01:40 PM
All The Whey Testimonials	Spaceman Spiff	Supplements	0	05-05-2007 02:46 PM
Power Protein Shake Recipes	Robert D.	Diet & Nutrition	0	04-24-2007 09:10 PM
protien powder vs. protien in food	SKINSFAN	Diet & Nutrition	3	04-01-2001 11:07 PM

06-25-2001, 04:28 AM	#2
w8lifter Join Date: May 2001 Location: Around..... Posts: 14,964	I think you need some serious food in the morning there. Are you not hungry? I'd be starving! Food isn't a bad thing. Eating a good breakfast will ensure that you make healthier food choices later in the day because you won't be starving. As for eating after working out, it's common practice to drink a liquid shake (or smoothie) right after working out because liquid form is digested the fasted. Personally, if I have time, I take a shake right after, then cook a meal of protein and carbs and eat that 30-45 minutes later. But, sometimes I just have the meal. In your case, since you haven't had food for so long, I'd be eating a good meal. You don't say what type of workout you're doing...cardio or weights. If you're doing weights after only having a shake 2 hours earlier, you may get a better workout (lift heavier, last longer) if you eat a decent breaky w/ some complex carbs. Oats w/ a scoop of protein added will take you further than just the shake alone. Anyway, jmo

06-25-2001, 10:30 AM	#4
LogreBeast Registered User Join Date: Jun 2001 Location: Austin, TX, 78705 Posts: 5	Sorry for the lack of details. I am a 6'8" guy.I'm 19. I used to weigh 280 lbs, i'm now down to 245 which is my ideal weight. I was never obese, i am just a very big guy. My goal is to get lean. About like Edward Norton in American Histroy X (my favorite movie). The shake is a meal replacement that i take. it has 26 grams of carbs in it. It is a meal replacement shake. I'm not hungry at all. I found out today that the shake also contains some Casein Protein as well as egg protein and more. It is a very good shake. It's the B-Fit RX shake from Bally's. In the morning i take the Lite Version, which contains the 20 grams. I work out on the weights. I don't do heavy lifting. I do high volume. Like lower weight. A mid way amount of reps, but more sets. Like on bench i do about 5 sets of 10 or 12. I work out about 5 or 6 days a week. I need more cardio. During the regular year, i play a lot of basketball. So that won't be a problem. But for now i do occasional swimming. And even less occasional running. After i have the 2nd shake, my meals consist of things like a chicken sandwich with mustard a lot of lettuce and and lean chicken that has about 20 grams of protein and 3 grams of fat or so. Then i have another sandwich later on. about 4 hrs later. And the end of the night i have a small amount of Tuna to keep my stomach busy at night. Sometimes during the day i have a smoothie that i make of my own. It only contains natural fruits that i buy at the store. I put strawberries, grapes, and either one or two bananas. Thanks for all the help guys. I really appreciate the input.