Should i be drinking protein shakes? [Forum Archive]

Pages: 1

Should i be drinking protein shakes?

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Posted by: Duster

Stats
6' 1"
283 lbs
31% BF

I have been working out steady for 5 months now and i started at 270 lbs and 35% BF. While i want to both maintain and increase my lean body mass my main goal is to cut my BF. I eat pretty clean keeping my protein high. No fast food or soda try to stay at 3000 or less calories a day. My question is would i be better served at this point with such a high BF% to stop drinking protein shakes and just stick to a clean diet high in protein? would this hinder my strength gains? am i better off letting my body turn the mass that i have into muscle or do i need to add protein from the shakes?

Posted by: m11

For all intents and purposes, the protein in food is the same as the protein in the shakes.

Supplementation with protein shakes is not contingent on what your goals are, but more so on whether or not you require the convenience of protein shakes.

Posted by: BlueCorsair

Shakes are a great way to meet your requirements without having to have "bigger" foods, or bringing along a host of other calories or things you don't neccessarily want along for the ride; I'd cite cottage cheese as an example. Cottage cheese is an awesome source of protein, don't get me wrong, but it is absolutely loaded with salt, and carries a slight carb load as well - at least more than a shake does. I try to limit myself to no more than one cup per day of the stuff, as the salt content in particular is just crazy.

Balance is truly the key, but there are definitely days that I get most of what I need protein-wise from shakes! In bulk, it's often cheaper than chicken!

Posted by: bodyforum1

Protein juice is good alternative to protein shakes.

Choosing the juice over the shake is that the juice doesn't make your stomach hurt, while the protein shake can sometimes do.

Posted by: T_man

Protein shakes are good but I wouldn't overdo them because there's a whole host of nutrients you need from other protein sources.

Posted by: danzik17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Duster

Stats
6' 1"
283 lbs
31% BF

I have been working out steady for 5 months now and i started at 270 lbs and 35% BF. While i want to both maintain and increase my lean body mass my main goal is to cut my BF. I eat pretty clean keeping my protein high. No fast food or soda try to stay at 3000 or less calories a day. My question is would i be better served at this point with such a high BF% to stop drinking protein shakes and just stick to a clean diet high in protein? would this hinder my strength gains? am i better off letting my body turn the mass that i have into muscle or do i need to add protein from the shakes?

I think you sound a bit confused about the process. Your mass isn't "turned" into muscle, muscle is built from excess calories and muscle stimulus. Fat is lost via a calorie deficit meaning that you need to eat less than you burn.

Except for a magical newbie period of maybe 1-2 months, you aren't going to be doing both.

You should post up your diet for review (total calories and the macronutrient breakdown - go to fitday.com if you need help figuring that out).

Posted by: Triple Threat

Of course you should be drinking protein shakes. Once I tried eating one, but it took me forever because the stuff kept falling off the fork.

Posted by: njc

Quote:

Originally Posted by Triple Threat

Of course you should be drinking protein shakes. Once I tried eating one, but it took me forever because the stuff kept falling off the fork.

lol

awesome

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36