Glutamine and Creatine at the same time?? is ok?? [Forum Archive]

Pages: 1

Glutamine and Creatine at the same time?? is ok??

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Posted by: papaoso2k1

I read somewhere that you are not supposed to take creatine and glutamine at the same time..heres the link
http://www.mens-fitness-tips.com/www...upplements.htm
What do you think about it?? does it sound right or is it just bull??

Posted by: oaktownboy

that's pure bullshit papaoso..i've had creatine that included glutamine with it...both all muscle builders and help restore glycogen reserve levels...
BTW, MAGAZINES LIKE FLEX, M&F, AND MENS FITNESS ARE FULL OF SHIT AND I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THAT U DON'T READ OR BUY THEM ANYMORE.THEY ARE VERY .MISLEADING

Posted by: papaoso2k1

thx dude...I dont buy them anyway...(they are not cheap here in venezuela)..and I spend enough on supplements and food already..

Posted by: oaktownboy

Well Well Well lookie what i found at bb.com

"Glutamine should not be taken at the same time as creatine because they compete for receptors to be absorbed. Take glutamine pre-workout and creatine post-workout."

This should help.

Posted by: papaoso2k1

now you re confusing me again

Posted by: oaktownboy

to answer your original question...No don't take them at the same time.Take glutamine pre-workout and creatine post-workout. That's what the website said and it makes sense.Then the muscle cells won't be competing for one or the other cause ur taking them at different times. make sense now?

Posted by: gr81

Quote:

Originally posted by oaktownboy
..i've had creatine that included glutamine with it...both all muscle builders and help restore glycogen reserve levels..

Glutamine is not a muscle builder oaktown.

Posted by: oaktownboy

glutamine replenishes glycogen reserves, which in turns leads to the formation of muscle

Posted by: oaktownboy

Research shows that after intensely working out, glutamine levels in the body are reduced by as much as 50%. Since the body relies on glutamine as cellular fuel for the immune system, scientific studies have shown that glutamine supplementation can minimize the breakdown of muscle tissue and improve protein metabolism. Its effects on replenishing the body after stress or trauma have been shown in Europe where it is commonly given to patients in hospitals. Glutamine's cell-volumizing effects have also been shown in several studies. No conclusive studies have been done to evaluate the effects of L-glutamine supplementation on weight-training adults; however, a recent study showed up to a 400% increase in growth-hormone levels when as little as 2 grams of free-form L-glutamine supplement was consumed!

Posted by: Makaveli_786

What about taking big doses of Glutamine like 30 grams pre-workout and 15 grams post-workout? I heard this gives you amazing pumps, motivation and keeps you pain free.

Posted by: TheDude

Quote:

Glutamine should not be taken at the same time as creatine because they compete for receptors to be absorbed.

Without very specific evidence, this is pseudo-science.

This sounds to me like "don't drink water with your meal, because the water will compete with the food for intestinal absorbtion points". Of course, that doesn't happen - eventually your intestines absorb the whole thing.

There's no evidence given here or in the link that the receptors are insufficient to accomodate both. 10 people may "compete" for places on a soccer team, but since a soccer team has 11 players, it doesn't matter.

Quote:

Take glutamine pre-workout and creatine post-workout.

This makes even less sense. One of creatine's benefits is that it helps you workout more intensely - which it can hardly do if you take it after the workout! And glutamine's most celebrated benefit is in recovery - so it should be taken after working out.

Posted by: oaktownboy

Quote:

Originally posted by TheDude
This makes even less sense. One of creatine's benefits is that it helps you workout more intensely - which it can hardly do if you take it after the workout! And glutamine's most celebrated benefit is in recovery - so it should be taken after working out.
people tend to take creatine postworkout dude try again

Posted by: oaktownboy

Quote:

Posted by: oaktownboy

ok sure whatever u want

Posted by: oaktownboy

Quote:

Originally posted by Makaveli_786
What about taking big doses of Glutamine like 30 grams pre-workout and 15 grams post-workout? I heard this gives you amazing pumps, motivation and keeps you pain free.
Your body can only digest a certain amount for each session.That's why it is recommended to take 5g of glutamine per serving.It's easier assimilated.

Posted by: kdwa1

I take Glutamine and Creatine together every am and feel great,who needs coffee.I Also take Glutamine pre and post workout for quick recovery.Too much creatine is stressy and gives me insomnia.Anyway it all gets absorbed like mixing different foods.Optimum might be seperate however.

Posted by: TheDude

Quote:

I take Glutamine and Creatine together every am and feel great,who needs coffee.

By the way, Glutamine is a vasodilator, and coffee is a vasoconstrictor, so they are not replacements for each other!

But, if Glutamine/Creatine gets you going, then one less cup of coffee can only benefit your health.

Posted by: OceanDude

I do glutamine both pre and post workout. In the post I mix it in with creatine. Frankly, I suspect most of the post workout glutamine never gets past the intenstines since it's a perfect food for them.

Posted by: ST240

Quote:

Ive heard that anything over 10 grams just gets flushed out.... dont quote me on that tho

Posted by: oaktownboy

it's more like 5 g That's why companies recommend 5g servings

Posted by: the Scarab

when is the best time to take creatine and glutamine on the days you don't work out? and/or should you take them both as much

Posted by: oaktownboy

first thing in the morning for creatine right before bed for glutamine on off days

Posted by: kdwa1

Can you guys sleep on Glutamine?I definitely can't on creatine.

Posted by: naturalguy

That is old science that states that they shouldn't be taken together. It is fine to take them together, they do not compete with absorbtion.

Posted by: TheDude

While web surfing, I came across more information on this.

Free Form L-Glutamine (most of what you see for sale as a separate product) supposedly does not work well in combination with anything else (Creatine, protein, food, juice, etc.). Thus it supposedly should be ingested separately from everything else.

Glutamine Peptides, on the other hand, don't have this limitation, and if you look at the various mixes available, such as protein with glutamine, or creatine with glutamine, they almost always use Glutamine Peptides - even when the same brand doesn't sell Glutamine Peptides as a separate product.

Again, I'm not convinced that this claim is true, but if you use Glutamine Peptides, you'll avoid the problem - if it exists.

And, there is also evidence (ie scientific studies) showing that Glutamine Peptides produce more glutamine in the bloodstream than L-Glutamine, so you're probably better off with it anyway.

Posted by: Testosterone

L-Glutamine should never be taken with anything. It should be consumed with plain water. It works best after intense training and before going to bed.
Yes, Glutamine peptides can be taken with anything including your protein shakes!

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Glutamine and Creatine at the same time?? is ok??

Article Archives

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60