IronMagazine Bodybuilding Forums


IronMagLabs - Bodybuilding Supplements
Pages: 1 2

Should Bonds get an Asterisk?

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)




Posted by: Dale Mabry

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
I don't think to the extreme roids does, in fact I don't even respond to creatine....not like I did when I tried test. back in the late 80's.

So cheating is only wrong if it is extreme? The fields today are optimal, pitchers are better, there are set up pitchers, I could go on. If it wasn't against the rules there should be no asterisk.



Posted by: Twin Peak

Two words -- slippery slope.



Posted by: Dale Mabry

Quote:
Originally Posted by Twin Peak
Two words -- slippery slope.

Actually, he is African-American.



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by IainDaniel
Here you go Mino already looked into this earlier in the thread
Wow, need I say more.

That's the first time I ever heard of Babe Ruth using a corked bat.



Posted by: Twin Peak

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dale Mabry
Actually, he is African-American.
You are not at the top of your game today.



Posted by: Dale Mabry

I thought that was a very nice use of racial epithets.



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dale Mabry
So cheating is only wrong if it is extreme? The fields today are optimal, pitchers are better, there are set up pitchers, I could go on. If it wasn't against the rules there should be no asterisk.
The fields are much smaller and the Baseball is wound much tighter.

Also there is the fatigue factor, you have a lot of ballplayers losing steam late in tthe season.



Posted by: bio-chem

thats why its a joke to compare different generations. the hall of fame is for the best players of their time. and bond clearly is the best hitter of his generation. regardless of steroids the guy is an offensive machine. steroids (regardless of whether he used them) did not give him great dicipline in the strike zone (as evidenced by the amount of walks he gets a year) or teach him to hit a curve ball or slider. bonds deserves to be in regardless of steroids



Posted by: tucker01

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
That's the first time I ever heard of Babe Ruth using a corked bat.
http://catalyst.umdnj.edu/plexus/?article_id=171

not really a great source.

Also tampered bats were banned in 1923 after it was found out that Babe Ruth was using a laminated bat.



Posted by: min0 lee

Dear lord....not my Babe. I am going to forget I ever read this.



Posted by: Dale Mabry

Forget you read what? That he corked his bat, prolly the least of the ways he attempted to cheat.



Posted by: min0 lee

There is no proof.



Posted by: tucker01

True enough.

Trying to get advantages over you competitors has been around baseball as long as can be remembered. Should Gaylord Perry with stricken from the hall for using spitballs? Or Ty Cobb for sharpening his spikes? Or Phil Neikro for using an emery board to scuff the ball?



Posted by: min0 lee

It's just that he's about to break possibly the most treasured record in Baseball and that would be a crime in my eyes.
Same with the Maris record.



Posted by: Dale Mabry

Didn't they make rules in basketball based on the fact that Wilt Chamberlain dominated? I think they even made the lane wider. How is it fair that people today are competing under tougher rules?



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dale Mabry
Didn't they make rules in basketball based on the fact that Wilt Chamberlain dominated? I think they even made the lane wider. How is it fair that people today are competing under tougher rules?
Not fair at all.



Posted by: tucker01

Records are there to break if not what is the point of tracking them?



Posted by: min0 lee

True but let it be done without cheating.



Posted by: tucker01

Cheating has occured in every era. It seems to be a part of baseball.

And Steroids weren't cheating in baseball until just recently



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by IainDaniel
Cheating has occured in every era. It seems to be a part of baseball.

And Steroids weren't cheating in baseball until just recently
No, technically it wasn't but it's obvious it's banned in Football and the Olympics so these ballplayers should know better.



Posted by: tucker01

Players are going to take every rule to the limit to benefit there performance... and I see no problem with that. If I was a pro athelete, I would take advantage of every legal (by the rules of the governing sport) way to enhance my performance.

Who is at fault is MLB...for neglecting to address this, and even the recent applications are really just a slap on the wrist



Posted by: Dale Mabry

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
No, technically it wasn't but it's obvious it's banned in Football and the Olympics so these ballplayers should know better.

Alot of stuff is banned in the olympics that isn't in other sports. Some over-the-counter cough medicines are. In a 160+ game season, someone is likely to get a cold. Do they suffer?

You aren't allowed to use your hands in soccer, should that rule be adopted for football and baseball as well?



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by IainDaniel
Players are going to take every rule to the limit to benefit there performance... and I see no problem with that. If I was a pro athelete, I would take advantage of every legal (by the rules of the governing sport) way to enhance my performance.

Who is at fault is MLB...for neglecting to address this, and even the recent applications are really just a slap on the wrist
I agree, the Giant management had their a suspicions and knew Anderson was a shady character.



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dale Mabry
Alot of stuff is banned in the olympics that isn't in other sports. Some over-the-counter cough medicines are. In a 160+ game season, someone is likely to get a cold. Do they suffer?

You aren't allowed to use your hands in soccer, should that rule be adopted for football and baseball as well?
If they used their hands it would be basketball...you just love using your hands. Ghey



Posted by: Dale Mabry

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
If they used their hands it would be basketball...you just love using your hands. Ghey
No, you can't use your feet in basketball, so it is Bizarro Basketball.



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dale Mabry
No, you can't use your feet in basketball, so it is Bizarro Basketball.
No, Soccer is just bizarre.



Posted by: section8

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
No, Soccer is just bizarre.


anyways, if you give Bonds an asterisk, do you give Big Mac one also? He used Andro, and like Barry at the time there was no policy in place, but it is now an illegal performance enhancing substance. Just a thought. I don't like Bonds and have always thought he was a prick, but take nothing away from him, even before the roid years he was still a damn great hitter and one of the best I have seen. Like you said earlier if he was a nice guy and media friendly we wouldn't even be talking about this. I think that it is sad that he will be remembered most for the use of roids than his skills.



Posted by: mattd46612

Its all bullshit if it was all the gear then Jose Canseco would have 1000 home runs. No its still 90% talent, the guy can flat out hit the ball.



Posted by: min0 lee

Jose Canseco



Posted by: tucker01

Quote:
Originally Posted by mattd46612
Its all bullshit if it was all the gear then Jose Canseco would have 1000 home runs. No its still 90% talent, the guy can flat out hit the ball.
douche bad say what? Think a little before you post. Here is some food for thought

Quote:
Originally Posted by IainDaniel
No they won't you are right

Bonds already had an exceptional eye at the plate. Howvever the increased bat speed will make a huge difference. Now instead of not being able to get the bat around fast enough to fight off the inside pitch, Bonds can can get the meat of the bat around to make solid contact.

All those Deep fly balls now become Homruns from the increased BAt speed. Strike outs where he couldn't get the bat around now have the possibilty of being hits. There are so many scenarios of improvements to situations from improved bat speed, I could go on and on.

No one is arguing that he doesn't have a great eye at the plate and there is no doubt that steroids don't enhance that, but they are allowing him to take better advantage of his abilites.




Posted by: JOHNYORK

Bonds already had an exceptional eye at the plate. Howvever the increased bat speed will make a huge difference. Now instead of not being able to get the bat around fast enough to fight off the inside pitch, Bonds can can get the meat of the bat around to make solid contact.

All those Deep fly balls now become Homruns from the increased BAt speed. Strike outs where he couldn't get the bat around now have the possibilty of being hits. There are so many scenarios of improvements to situations from improved bat speed, I could go on and on.

No one is arguing that he doesn't have a great eye at the plate and there is no doubt that steroids don't enhance that, but they are allowing him to take better advantage of his abilites.


agreed



Posted by: JordanMang

Quote:
Originally Posted by JOHNYORK
Bonds already had an exceptional eye at the plate. Howvever the increased bat speed will make a huge difference. Now instead of not being able to get the bat around fast enough to fight off the inside pitch, Bonds can can get the meat of the bat around to make solid contact.

All those Deep fly balls now become Homruns from the increased BAt speed. Strike outs where he couldn't get the bat around now have the possibilty of being hits. There are so many scenarios of improvements to situations from improved bat speed, I could go on and on.

No one is arguing that he doesn't have a great eye at the plate and there is no doubt that steroids don't enhance that, but they are allowing him to take better advantage of his abilites.


agreed

Have you taken into consideration that maybe he's just leveling the playing field? I could careless if the batter is using roids when the 9 guys he's trying to overcome are as well ( including the guy throwing the ball to him ). I mean - if "so many other guys" in the league are juicing then no he shouldn't be getting an asterik because other players aren't playing handicapped.



Posted by: bio-chem

Quote:
Originally Posted by JOHNYORK
Bonds already had an exceptional eye at the plate. Howvever the increased bat speed will make a huge difference. Now instead of not being able to get the bat around fast enough to fight off the inside pitch, Bonds can can get the meat of the bat around to make solid contact.

All those Deep fly balls now become Homruns from the increased BAt speed. Strike outs where he couldn't get the bat around now have the possibilty of being hits. There are so many scenarios of improvements to situations from improved bat speed, I could go on and on.

No one is arguing that he doesn't have a great eye at the plate and there is no doubt that steroids don't enhance that, but they are allowing him to take better advantage of his abilites.


agreed
bat speed is an interesting arguement, but then how do you explain mark mcguires 49 home runs his rookie year or ken griffey jr's 500 plus home runs neither was in mcguire's case or jr's his whole carreer were big men with tremendous bat speed.



Posted by: busyLivin

I didn't read the whole thread, but Bonds shouldn't have an asterik, he should be stricken from the record books & banned from baseball.



Posted by: bio-chem

Quote:
Originally Posted by busyLivin
I didn't read the whole thread, but Bonds shouldn't have an asterik, he should be stricken from the record books & banned from baseball.
without ever testing positive for a substance that wasnt illegal in the sport till 2002? seems a little harsh. especially when a lot of hall of fame ball players have admitted to doing worse stuff



Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:
Originally Posted by busyLivin
I didn't read the whole thread, but Bonds shouldn't have an asterik, he should be stricken from the record books & banned from baseball.
It is naive to think many of his peers were not also using banned drugs, steroids and other drugs have been in most sports since the 70's......and who cares.



Posted by: busyLivin

it's just an insult to all the natural greats who did it through hard work & talent. Should Bonds' name really be above Babe Ruth's?

& I think all players who cheat should be banned, not just Bonds.



Posted by: min0 lee

Your posts deserve an asterik also since you also a user.
Cheater.



Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
Your posts deserve an asterik also since you also a user.
Cheater.

True Story.



Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForemanRules
It is naive to think many of his peers were not also using banned drugs, steroids and other drugs have been in most sports since the 70's......and who cares.





Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
Your posts deserve an asterik also since you also a user.
Cheater.
I would like to use you next



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by BigDyl
True Story.
There's no way he would have been able to have that many posts without the help of some juice.



Posted by: bio-chem

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee
There's no way he would have been able to have that many posts without the help of some juice.
apple juice?



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by bio-chem
apple juice?
Not Foreman. The closet he ever got to apple juice was when it was used for moonshine.



Posted by: tucker01

Quote:
Originally Posted by busyLivin
it's just an insult to all the natural greats who did it through hard work & talent. Should Bonds' name really be above Babe Ruth's?

& I think all players who cheat should be banned, not just Bonds.
There are many known cheats in the hall of fame.



Posted by: tucker01

Quote:
Originally Posted by bio-chem
bat speed is an interesting arguement, but then how do you explain mark mcguires 49 home runs his rookie year or ken griffey jr's 500 plus home runs neither was in mcguire's case or jr's his whole carreer were big men with tremendous bat speed.
Bat speed is only one part of the equation. There are many players who have more talents at batting, then other players.



Posted by: Big Smoothy

Bonds should get an asterisk at the minimum.

He records should not be considered.

As well as others.


It just ain't fair; it just ain't the same.

The question may be....should there be record of these different eras.



Posted by: tucker01

no he hit the homeruns. if he beats the record so be it.

This is MLB's problem not Barry, as much of a dick he may be. MLB was too worried about marketing after the strike in 94, to give two shits about steroids. Then the homeruns started flying and fans started flocking.

MLB and the owners are the biggest fuck ups here.



(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Should Bonds get an Asterisk?


Article Archives

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60