Is the Preacher Curl worth doing? [Forum Archive]

Pages: 1

Is the Preacher Curl worth doing?

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Posted by: Nick+

I bought a new (Weider)bench recently , with a solid preacher curl pad attachment thrown in........

Never done Preacher curls in my life before......So I'm finding them very hard to do with a very light weight (presently 16kgs/35lbs for 3 sets of less than 10 reps). Finding the day after that the biceps are very sore where they meet the elbow.

Is this exercise of any use and worth doing?

Posted by: TJ Cline

I do 2 sets most back workouts.

Posted by: PWGriffin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

I bought a new (Weider)bench recently , with a solid preacher curl pad attachment thrown in........

Never done Preacher curls in my life before......So I'm finding them very hard to do with a very light weight (presently 16kgs/35lbs for 3 sets of less than 10 reps). Finding the day after that the biceps are very sore where they meet the elbow.

Is this exercise of any use and worth doing?

If ur bi's are sore where they meet the elbow this is most likely the tendons and connective tissues that are sore and not the muscle itself...that will pass if you keep on with isolated curls...

Posted by: dougnukem

Yea, the soreness should pass. I used to do Preachers, but have been doing other movements as of late. ie: BB curls, DB curls, or hammer curls.

Posted by: Nick+

I do 2 sets most back workouts.

If ur bi's are sore where they meet the elbow this is most likely the tendons and connective tissues that are sore and not the muscle itself...that will pass if you keep on with isolated curls...

Sp preacher curls are an isolation exercise........ But standing bicep curls with a straight or EZ bar would not be?

Yea, the soreness should pass. I used to do Preachers, but have been doing other movements as of late. ie: BB curls, DB curls, or hammer curls.

Posted by: kenwood

yes i like preacher curls

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by kenwood

yes i like preacher curls

twice said: maximum impact

Posted by: MyK

I love preacher curls, only reason most people cant do them is because you cant do as much weight as with hammers.

I do dumbells, make sure you do a full range of motion!

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by MyK

I love preacher curls, only reason most people cant do them is because you cant do as much weight as with hammers.

I do dumbells, make sure you do a full range of motion!

Only tried BB so far- what damn bit of the arm are they supposed to hit anyway????

Posted by: PWGriffin

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

I do 2 sets most back workouts.

With standing bb curls you can use momentum to ur advantage and sway and swing the weight around...hence, why Preachers are harder and require you to knock the weight down a bit.

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

Only tried BB so far- what damn bit of the arm are they supposed to hit anyway????

bicep!!!!

Posted by: dougnukem

Quote:

Originally Posted by PWGriffin

With standing bb curls you can use momentum to ur advantage and sway and swing the weight around...hence, why Preachers are harder and require you to knock the weight down a bit.

So you mean you can't throw your shoulders into preachers?

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by dougnukem

So you mean you can't throw your shoulders into preachers?

not really no!

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

Only tried BB so far- what damn bit of the arm are they supposed to hit anyway????

do you have an EZ curl bar?

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by PWGriffin

With standing bb curls you can use momentum to ur advantage and sway and swing the weight around...hence, why Preachers are harder and require you to knock the weight down a bit.

Interesting. Yes, with standing EZ/straight bar curls, one can end up 'swinging the torso', (I've tried to avoid it as much as possible , and don't do very fast reps either ---5 seconds positive)

I still feel with the preacher (as I'm totally new to it) that it's hitting some other part of the arms....and I'm not saying this is bad. Just want to know more about it.........

Posted by: dougnukem

Quote:

Originally Posted by MyK

not really no!

Sure you can. Unless you do spider curls.

Posted by: TJ Cline

I like the peek they give to my biceps

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by MyK

do you have an EZ curl bar?

Yes, but been doing preacher with straight bar.

Posted by: TJ Cline

True story

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by ForemanRules

I like the peek they give to my biceps

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

Yes, but been doing preacher with straight bar.

hmm, the straight bar really hurts my wrists!!

Posted by: Nick+

So EZ or Straight better?

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

So EZ or Straight better?

my opinion is dumbell!

I'd say EZ over straight, but if the straight bar is comfortable for you, you can use it!

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by MyK

hmm, the straight bar really hurts my wrists!!

yea use EZ for reverse bicep and normal bicep curls now.
just thought I'd try the straight for something new.......

Posted by: dougnukem

It depends on the person. Some people get pain in their wrists with straight bars.

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by MyK

my opinion is dumbell!

I'd say EZ over straight, but if the straight bar is comfortable for you, you can use it!

Never tried DB's!!!!!

Posted by: dougnukem

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

Never tried DB's!!!!!

You're missing out then.

Posted by: Nick+

I've only got pains in the wrist since returning to the straight bar after the EZ (which I only bought a year ago) Used to have no wrist pains with the straight.........

Mind you I was probably using joke weights....

Posted by: MyK

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nick+

just thought I'd try the straight for something new.......

hey man, lets stick to the topic!

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by dougnukem

You're missing out then.

I'll try them out some time.

Posted by: dougnukem

It also can depends on your hand placement with a straight bar. A lot of folks take too narrow of a grip and put undo strain on their wrists.

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by dougnukem

It also can depends on your hand placement with a straight bar. A lot of folks take too narrow of a grip and put undo strain on their wrists.

The 'preacher {45°}pad' is narrower than my shoulder width. so I'm forced to do the exercise hands closer together. Any standing curl: I'll hold bar (straight or EZ) shoulder width.

Thats interesting, I wonder how much more strain could be caused by the hand being closer together.........

Posted by: The13ig13adWolf

regarding preacher curls, be sure to stay tight at the top of the movement rather than easing the tension.

Posted by: ABLQ2

i prefer an ez curl bar on the preacher curl station because the movement feels more natural.

the reason for your tendons being sore is because when you did normal standing curls, you probably failed to bring the weight all the way down to the bottom position where you bicep should be totally taught and (as the sticky says) you should be able to flex your tricep. i have no science to back up this reasoning but i noticed the same thing when i first began working out back in the day. when you really think about it though, the portion of a preacher curl where your arm is working hardest against gravity is the lower part of the lift - halfway through the lift, you just pull the weight back, rather than continue to bring it up. thats why i still prefer strait bar curls with my elbows pull slightly back. if you have trouble with your torso moving, put your back against the wall, or get a bicep blaster.

a lot of people fail to recognize that free weights have their weakness as well... they only work against gravity.

Posted by: CowPimp

The reason you find preacher curls hard to do is two-fold: muscles are designed to exert the most force when the moment arm is naturally the longest and because the force curve is altered from your standard curl variations.

Basically, the biceps exert the most force when your elbow is at a 90 degree angle because naturally that is where it will encounter the most resistance. When you put your elbows on an angled pad, you now encounter the most resistance at a more obtuse angle.

Also, because the force curve is altered in this manner, you are not very neurologically efficient at following this pattern compared to a plethora of other curl variations. Your strength will probably get a little burst initially and then taper off as your adapt.

Posted by: Nick+

Thanks, good info .

I'll stick with the straight bar for the minute...............(as I'm using the EZ standing, just for variety)

Posted by: lil2fiddyguy

I have only tried them a couple times. I was kicked out of church for it though. dOh! bad jokE. ctrl+z ctrl+z!!

Posted by: musclepump

If done properly then preachers curls are fantastic.

Posted by: Tier

I do DB preacher curls, Barbell standing curls, then hammer curls
2 sets each

Posted by: BoneCrusher

As everyone else is saying preachers rock. I love preachers and highly recommend you build them into your workouts. They do tend to show the weak spots in your bi's as you've already noticed. If the pain is in the sides of your bi's close to the elbow go very easy and light till that pain backs off or you will tear your bicep like I did ... it really sucks. Sat me out for eight frickin months before I healed up well enough to lift heavily again.

Anyways enjoy the preachers mayn.

Posted by: Nick+

Quote:

Originally Posted by BoneCrusher

As everyone else is saying preachers rock. I love preachers and highly recommend you build them into your workouts. They do tend to show the weak spots in your bi's as you've already noticed. If the pain is in the sides of your bi's close to the elbow go very easy and light till that pain backs off or you will tear your bicep like I did ... it really sucks. Sat me out for eight frickin months before I healed up well enough to lift heavily again.

Anyways enjoy the preachers mayn.

After the last workout my biceps near the elbow were very sore for about three days . And that's after using sod all weight {17kgs/37lbs x 5reps + 15kgs/33lbs x 10 + 8 reps}. I'll go easy on the weight after hearing about tears .......

I'm quite accomplished at doing my back in(every couple of months) , don't want to start wrecking the biceps too.........

Posted by: DOMS

Preachers are great. The reason that you can only use so little weight is that they're a single-joint exercise (isolation) and you can't use any body English to work it up.

As for you're bicep hurting close to the elbow, yes, like PWGriffin said, it's likely the tendon. What little I've read about suggests that improper preacher curls can cause damage to the tendon. Just make sure that you warm up first and that you use muscle to bring the weight down and not gravity. As always, don't let your ego decide how much weight to lift.

The soreness that I experienced went away after a while. Just give it some time.

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Is the Preacher Curl worth doing?

Article Archives

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60