Sylvia VERSUS Emelianko [Forum Archive]

-->

Pages: 1

Sylvia VERSUS Emelianko

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Posted by: BigDyl

Tim called out Fedor. Who would win?

Discuss.

Posted by: fufu

ummmm. Fedor.

Posted by: bigss75

I don't know. Fedor is really good, but Tim hasn't fought anyone that quality, I think he could rise to the occasion and make it a good fight.

Posted by: SuperFlex

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

Tim called out Fedor. Who would win?

Discuss.

Posted by: goandykid

Thats not even a fight

Posted by: fUnc17

ahahahahaha.. sylvia will get worked.

Posted by: Martinogdenbsx

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

Tim called out Fedor. Who would win?

Discuss.

There's nothing to discuss it's too obvious

Posted by: bigss75

Fedor has not fought a true quality heavyweight since Mark Coleman which is over two years ago. All his oppents have been either under 230 or that one obese slob.

Posted by: Martinogdenbsx

I repeat

Quote:

There's nothing to discuss it's too obvious

Posted by: The Monkey Man

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

Tim called out Fedor. Who would win?

Me!
When I press you over my head and hurl your body down the mountain!

Posted by: ReproMan

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigss75

Fedor has not fought a true quality heavyweight since Mark Coleman which is over two years ago. All his oppents have been either under 230 or that one obese slob.

Agreed. As is the case with most of the Pride fighters. The best fighters in the world are in Pride, but the talent pool is VERY shallow. You have a few guys at the top and then there's nobody else. They are so dominant because they fight nobodys, and in this case, Mark Coleman hasn't been a top heavyweight since the late 90's.

Posted by: Doublebase

That would be an excellent fight. I really don't know who to choose. That's a tough one.

Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Monkey Man

Me!
When I press you over my head and hurl your body down the mountain!

Please, I saw your training logs. You can barely overhead press 85 LB's.

Posted by: kuso

Tim would seriously shit his pants again....as he did when he fought Silva. This time it would not be due to any flu though.

Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigss75

Fedor has not fought a true quality heavyweight since Mark Coleman which is over two years ago. All his oppents have been either under 230 or that one obese slob.

Nog isn't a "true quality" heavy weight? What about Cro Cop?

Posted by: bigss75

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

Nog isn't a "true quality" heavy weight? What about Cro Cop?

They are both in the 215-230 range, he hasnt seen a guy over 240 since 2004

Posted by: kuso

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigss75

They are both in the 215-230 range, he hasnt seen a guy over 240 since 2004

Zulu.

Posted by: bigss75

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuso

Zulu.

If that 400 pound blob is considered a top opponent for Fedor, Pride has an extremel shallow talent pool. Plus the way Fedor handled him it shouldnt be considered a fight

Posted by: kuso

No MMA fan could ever say PRIDE's HW talent pool is shallow when the comparison is UFC........who have really two decent guys.

At the end of the day, Fedor has beaten better ground guys than Tim, better stand up guys than Tim, way bigger fighters than Tim, and big guys that are far better at striking than Tim (Sem).

And no HW fighter forces their own gameplan on their opponent throughout the entire fight better than Fedor.

Posted by: ReproMan

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuso

No MMA fan could ever say PRIDE's HW talent pool is shallow when the comparison is UFC........who have really two decent guys.

At the end of the day, Fedor has beaten better ground guys than Tim, better stand up guys than Tim, way bigger fighters than Tim, and big guys that are far better at striking than Tim (Sem).

And no HW fighter forces their own gameplan on their opponent throughout the entire fight better than Fedor.

I love how in the other thread you say making comparisons between the 2 organizations is gay. Yet here you are.....

Nobody is doubting the fact that Fedor would hand Tim his ass, but they are arguing that it's such an open and shut case that Pride is SO MUCH BETTER than UFC. Granted the top few guys are, but there is a steep drop off after the top 3 or 4 in Pride and any top guy in the UFC could and would give them a run for their money. Not to mention it all depends on what rules they'd be using. I think Silva is a better and more well rounded fighter than Liddell, but the fact they'll be fighting in a octogon and under UFC's rules defientely plays more into Liddell's hands.

P.S. I saw 2 MMA fans say it

Posted by: kuso

Quote:

Originally Posted by FatCatMC

I love how in the other thread you say making comparisons between the 2 organizations is gay. Yet here you are.....

You appear to have completely missed my point then.

I make no comparison at all between the orgs. There is a very real difference in the levels of the largest weight division of both companies though, and one which even the largest hater or nuthugger of either cannot deny and expect to be taken seriously.

Posted by: ReproMan

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuso

There is a very real difference in the levels of the largest weight division of both companies though

And this I agree with. Sylvia wouldn't be in the top 5 in Pride, but to make a blanket statement that Pride is better than UFC is just plain retarded.

Posted by: kuso

Quote:

Originally Posted by FatCatMC

but to make a blanket statement that Pride is better than UFC is just plain retarded.

I believe I said much the same 24 hours or so ago.

Posted by: TJ Cline

Any top 10 heavyweight boxer would KO him in 2-4 seconds.

Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:

Originally Posted by ForemanRules

Any top 10 heavyweight boxer would KO him in 2-4 seconds.

Not Fedor, SON!

Posted by: kuso

Quote:

Originally Posted by ForemanRules

Any top 10 heavyweight boxer would KO him in 2-4 seconds.

In MMA rules?

Posted by: BigDyl

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuso

In MMA rules?

I'll KO you, SON!

Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

Not Fedor, SON!

Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:

Originally Posted by kuso

In MMA rules?

Posted by: JordanMang

Quote:

Originally Posted by ForemanRules

Any top 10 heavyweight boxer would KO him in 2-4 seconds.

I agree. Standing up. But, if Fedor get them on the ground you'd see a fight end quick.

Posted by: BigDyl

I disagree. The boxer may tap fedor in the face a few times, but with fedors iron jaw, it's just like a mosquito flying around, and he will quickly clinch up with the boxer, and do a nasty uchi kari takedown or something like it. Then it's over.

Posted by: 911=InsideJob

My thinking is is that if Arlovski could drop Sylvia in 2 fights, and tag him several times in the third, then Fedor who is a lot more explosives could also drop Syvia as well. In Arlovski/Sylvia II, Sylvia was dropped and then got back up. If that were against Fedor, Fedor would jump right on top of Sylvia immediatly and do some serious ground and pound or go for a quick ass submission on Sylvia's long limbs.

Posted by: kuso

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDyl

I disagree. The boxer may tap fedor in the face a few times, but with fedors iron jaw, it's just like a mosquito flying around, and he will quickly clinch up with the boxer, and do a nasty uchi kari takedown or something like it. Then it's over.

I assume you missed his fights against Fujita and Mirko.

Posted by: Doublebase

Quote:

Originally Posted by ForemanRules

Any top 10 heavyweight boxer would KO him in 2-4 seconds.

Any top heavyweight MMA fighter would submit a top 10 heavyweight boxer in 2-4 seconds.

Posted by: Doublebase

Fedor.

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38