|
|
|
Originally Posted by PreMier
Ok, lets say I sleep 6 hours at night, then get a 1-2 hour nap during the day.. will I recover just as well if I slept 7-8hrs straight at night?
|
|
Originally Posted by PreMier
Thanks for the insight.. I work long hours, so I tend to sleep 6 or so hours at night, then nap in the mid day. Looks like I will just have to try and get more sleep.
|
|
Originally Posted by Trouble
HAN, you twist my words again, but not deliberately I think.
Let me clarify: As a temporary stop gap (not daily), for the occasional missed nights sleep (anxiety, illness, extenuating circumstances), short naps (cat naps are OK). Longer sleep, 1 or more hours, not good --> disturbs sleep cycling Chronic reliance on naps mid-day is a bad idea --> its stop gap, not a replacement for missed sleep at night --> sign of elevated cortisol tail, blunted peak and elevated night time cortisol --> can lead to adrenal insufficiency --> can result in hypopituitary / hpogonadal issues in adult years |
|
Originally Posted by Trouble
*sarcastic tone*
Maybe the current health crisis and the thought of having a hefty percentage of our population on $600+/month chronic symptom supression medication will be incentive enough... Or maybe not. We are inured to the "just in time" mentality. Why fix today what you can put off until tommow? |
|
Originally Posted by CowPimp
Good question Premier. Sometimes I am simply not able to get sufficient sleep in one fell swoop. Anyone else who is or was a personal trainer knows the fucked up hours you have to work to make it.
I don't get home until 10:30 most nights of the week, and sometimes I have to be awake at 4:30 the next morning, 5:30 at the latest. I am usually asleep by 11:30, so I grab 5 hours, 6 if I'm lucky, but I definitely need a 1-3 hour nap mid day if that happens or I just feel like shit. To make up for it, I don't work mornings Tuesday and Thursday. Those days I get a cool 8 hours of sleep, and sometimes a bit more. I don't think I could handle this schedule otherwise. I do try and get some decent sleep (7+ hours a night) on the weekends too. So, usually 3 days a week I get sleep in 2 parts, and the other 4 I get a solid bout of sleep in one session. Do you think this is a reasonable way to combat the odd hours I have to work? |
|
Originally Posted by BigDyl
You may have to do the best you can until you can work your way out of the situation. If you are still making gains, and are keeping relatively sane, then don't stress. Although I'm sure Trouble will mention it's screwing you circadian rythm up. I believe that can be fixed when the time is right though.
Sincerely, BigD |
|
Originally Posted by Trouble
I'll be back tomorrow to answer this thread. I think we need to chat about sleep phasing and its physiology.
|
|
Originally Posted by Trouble
Thank, D, for the thoughtful recommendation. I did just that - took a break on Saturday to go hear excellent jazz at a semi-local jazz fest. I did a little on line work yesterday morning and evening, but managed to get in some relaxation and a useful trip to stock up on supplies, while enjoying unseasonably cool conditions.
Sure wish I could get that massage; touch therapy has manyfold benefits. Beg pardon for my delay in replying to your missives (needed the break this past weekend). |
|
Originally Posted by Trouble
Tradeoffs for adequate rest are NOT an option. Need to find ways to fix your schedule. Don't say you can't do it; you can.
|
|
Originally Posted by PreMier
Ok, lets say I sleep 6 hours at night, then get a 1-2 hour nap during the day.. will I recover just as well if I slept 7-8hrs straight at night?
|
|
Originally Posted by SuperFlex
It's still good to get the rest. Even a 30 minute nap helps...
|
|
Had to chew on this question for a while to understand it.
What I believe happened: this was a short-term period of sleep disruption. You found that periods of sleep that appear to re-balance neurochemistry and the associated excitatory activity within brain centers (so-called de-synchonization of the brain). Call it base-line reset. Its really what it this REM sleep appears to be, a reset button that allows you daily to cope with new larger and minor stressors (emotional, physical, environmental) without accumulating damage from these daily (chronic) exposure periods. Biomedical evidence for this supposition: Purpose of REM sleep: endogenous anti-epileptogenesis in man -- a hypothesis. Jaseja H. Med Hypotheses. 2004;62(4):546-8. Neuro-scientists, worldwide, are endeavoring to elucidate the purpose of sleep which still remains largely elusive. There is, however, consensus on many aspects of sleep functions; one such aspect is its relationship with seizures/epilepsy. There is unequivocal agreement on increased susceptibility to epilepsy during nonrapid eye movement (NREM, slow-wave) sleep. Large number of studies have shown increased frequency of seizures and epilepti-form discharges in epileptic patients during NREM sleep (esp., stages I and II) which is associated with EEG synchronization. Similarly, there is widespread acceptance of de-synchronized brain-activity states being associated with rarity/total absence of epileptic potentials, one such state being rapid eye movement (REM) sleep. Certain drugs and substances which inhibit NREM sleep have been found to possess anti-convulsant properties. Not surprisingly, drugs/chemicals which enhance/promote NREM sleep or suppress/inhibit REM sleep are associated with increased susceptibility to seizures and are contraindicated in epilepsy. The manner and pattern in which REM phase occurs in sleep are also naturally programmed to exert anti-epileptogenic influence. This hypothesis-article highlights and conceptualizes the primary function of REM-sleep as endogenous anti-epileptogenic system in the body akin to the endogenous analgesia and immune systems man is born with. Seizures can be thought of as massed charges that build up like static in the air before a thunderstorm. This rem sleep acts to difuse this buildup and turn the brain system down to "low" setting, to allow healing and tissue recovery and rebuilding to occur nightly. So, when you don't have this REM sleep period, you feel foggy, maybe a little nauseous, disoriented, maybe have a short-temper, and a hard time concentrating and retaining information. Why? Probably because the brain centers needed for normal mental function need to be reset, returned to a normalized baseline state of normalized biochemical activity. Not sure if this makes sense. Jim. There is no 'right' explanation for your observation. Just a little clever guesswork based on current opinion/theory. |
|
1: Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2006 Aug 29; [Epub ahead of print]Click here to read Links Daytime Napping After a Night of Sleep Loss Decreases Sleepiness, Improves Performance, and Causes Beneficial Changes in Cortisol and Interleukin-6 Secretion. * Vgontzas AN, * Pejovic S, * Zoumakis E, * Lin HM, * Bixler EO, * Basta M, * Fang J, * Sarrigiannidis A, * Chrousos GP. Psychiatry, Sleep Research and Treatment Center, Penn State College of Medicine, Hershey, Pennsylvania, United States. Abstract Sleep loss has been associated with increased sleepiness, decreased performance, elevations in inflammatory cytokines, and insulin resistance. Daytime napping has been promoted as a countermeasure to sleep loss. To assess the effects of a 2-hour mid-afternoon nap following a night of sleep loss on post-nap sleepiness, performance, cortisol, and interleukin-6 (IL-6), 41 young healthy individuals (20 men, 21 women) participated in a 7-day sleep deprivation experiment (four consecutive nights followed by a night of sleep loss and two recovery nights). Half of the subjects were randomly assigned to take a mid-afternoon nap (1400-1600) the day following the night of total sleep loss. Serial 24-hour blood sampling, multiple sleep latency test (MSLT), subjective levels of sleepiness, and psychomotor vigilance task (PVT) were completed on the fourth (pre-deprivation) and sixth days (post-deprivation). During the nap, subjects had a significant drop in cortisol and IL-6 levels (P< 0.05), while after the nap, they experienced significantly less sleepiness (MSLT and subjective) (P< 0.05) and a smaller improvement on the PVT (P< 0.1). At this time, they had a significant transient increase in their cortisol levels (P< 0.05). In contrast, the levels of IL-6 tended to remain decreased for approximately eight hours (P = 0.1). We conclude that a 2-hour mid-afternoon nap improves alertness and to a lesser degree performance and reverses the effects of one night of sleep loss on cortisol and IL-6. The redistribution of cortisol secretion and the prolonged suppression of IL-6 secretion are beneficial, as they improve alertness and performance. Key words: cortisol, IL-6, alertness, napping, Sleep loss. PMID: 16940468 [PubMed - as supplied by publisher] |
| My own experience is that a long nap screws up the following nights sleep quality and I find myself wired at 11pm. |
|
I never claimed they didn't have a benefit. I reported that sleep biochemistry studies have shown that *chronic* reliance on afternoon naps to offset poor sleep habits has a negative impact on plasma cortisol, insulin control, immune response and autonomic system function.
Note that the effects of missed sleep are *almost identical* to those of early morning exercise in the fasted state. Note also that cortisol spiked after the nap - an echo of normal cortisol release after sleep sufficient to induce REM brain state. However, we don't want a chronic spike in cortisol in the early evening hours - it disrupts melatonin formation and release later on in the evening hours. Nice citation, Gordo. Thanks for mentioning it. I guess the question becomes...is there a nap duration that is best? The recommendations I've seen are to avoid lengthy naps, keeping them to 30 min. My own experience is that a long nap screws up the following nights sleep quality and I find myself wired at 11pm. |
|
I don't know about anyone else, but I have never slept for more than 3 hours at a time without waking up at night.. wake up, go back to sleep, wake up, try to go back to sleep. Even with melatonin, the same thing, only with taking melatonin it made me groggy the next day....
Maybe I'm just a very light sleeper |
|
Ok, lets say I sleep 6 hours at night, then get a 1-2 hour nap during the day.. will I recover just as well if I slept 7-8hrs straight at night?
|
|
I dont think anyone is meant to sleep in a near unconscious state for 8 straight hours. Sleep goes in cycles. So long as the next day you feel refreshed, i would say your previous nights sleep is good.
|
|
Oh, and I never do fasted cardio. It's practically pointless in my opinion.
|