Pages: 1

If I Just Lift for Hypertrophy......

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)






Posted by: the_general64

say im benching in the 7-9 rep range w/ 3-5 min rest intervals........and my 1RM is 365............if i start lifting in the 7-9 rep range but change rest interval to 1min or less (which is supposed to promote hypertrophy) after months of training like this, will my strength go up? will it remain the same? or will it decrease?



Posted by: Witchblade

You can't gain mass without gaining strength, really.



Posted by: the_general64

so should i start training like this.................in your opinion?



Posted by: pengers84

Decreasing the recovery period will most likely make strength gains slower, not stop them altogether.

If your top goal is hypertrophy, then yes train like that. If your top goal is strength stick with the longer recovery period.



Posted by: Witchblade

Agreed. RI of about 1,5min seem right to me. You should find out what fits for you and take that. Somewhere between 1-2min likely.



Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:
Originally Posted by Witchblade View Post
You can't gain mass without gaining strength, really.
I agree with this but some here do not believe in science. Hope they log on and try to convince us the world is flat.



Posted by: P-funk

Quote:
Originally Posted by the_general64 View Post
say im benching in the 7-9 rep range w/ 3-5 min rest intervals........and my 1RM is 365............if i start lifting in the 7-9 rep range but change rest interval to 1min or less (which is supposed to promote hypertrophy) after months of training like this, will my strength go up? will it remain the same? or will it decrease?
the only way your strength wouldn't go up is if you just stopped pushing yourself to put more weight on the bar.

people make this shit complicated. if you want to get better and improve just work on putting more weight on the bar.



Posted by: swordfish

thats where i disagree with you p funk, while getting stronger generally equate to getting bigger, its not all about the absolute weight on the bar.....

( perhaps you are suggesting though that the form doesnt loosen up while you increase the weight, if thats the case which im sure it is then of course it comes down to Ultimately putting more weight on, but nevertheless some may not undersand and might simply just throw more on in the quest to more muscle.)

for example, barbell rows


- one peron does 275 for 2 sets of 8
- another person does 225 for 2 sets of 8

if the peron doing 275 has loose form and isnt controlling the weight much
the person that does 225 can experience much more muscle growth and strength if these things happen- 2 or more seconds on the negative, strong contraction/squeeze at the top, controlling the weight, and FEELING THE MUSCLE WORK, (there may be a few more things so feel free to add to them)

you can get a better workout with a lighter weight AND MAKE THE MUSCLE WORK HARDER WITH THE LIGHTER WEIGHT,

if the person doing the 275 starts to perform the same as the 225 guy then obviously the person doing 275 will have a better workout....

you get my point



Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:
Originally Posted by swordfish View Post
thats where i disagree with you p funk, while getting stronger generally equate to getting bigger, its not all about the absolute weight on the bar.....

( perhaps you are suggesting though that the form doesnt loosen up while you increase the weight, if thats the case which im sure it is then of course it comes down to Ultimately putting more weight on, but nevertheless some may not undersand and might simply just throw more on in the quest to more muscle.)

for example, barbell rows


- one peron does 275 for 2 sets of 8
- another person does 225 for 2 sets of 8

if the peron doing 275 has loose form and isnt controlling the weight much
the person that does 225 can experience much more muscle growth and strength if these things happen- 2 or more seconds on the negative, strong contraction/squeeze at the top, controlling the weight, and FEELING THE MUSCLE WORK, (there may be a few more things so feel free to add to them)

you can get a better workout with a lighter weight AND MAKE THE MUSCLE WORK HARDER WITH THE LIGHTER WEIGHT,

if the person doing the 275 starts to perform the same as the 225 guy then obviously the person doing 275 will have a better workout....

you get my point
I don't think anyone gets your point.



Posted by: the_general64

as far as strict form goes......i've read that you can cheat a little. if you start off using strict form but toward the end of your reps you can cheat a little. is that bull?



Posted by: AKIRA

Quote:
Originally Posted by the_general64 View Post
as far as strict form goes......i've read that you can cheat a little. if you start off using strict form but toward the end of your reps you can cheat a little. is that bull?
Eh, not really "bull." However, its not really a good idea to keep that as a safety net. Cheating on some lifts can hurt you..physically. Deads, squats, bench, rows. Cheating on curls for example is not too bad, if done exactly how you say, but I dont think the rewards will be great.



Posted by: P-funk

Quote:
Originally Posted by swordfish View Post
thats where i disagree with you p funk, while getting stronger generally equate to getting bigger, its not all about the absolute weight on the bar.....

( perhaps you are suggesting though that the form doesnt loosen up while you increase the weight, if thats the case which im sure it is then of course it comes down to Ultimately putting more weight on, but nevertheless some may not undersand and might simply just throw more on in the quest to more muscle.)

for example, barbell rows


- one peron does 275 for 2 sets of 8
- another person does 225 for 2 sets of 8

if the peron doing 275 has loose form and isnt controlling the weight much
the person that does 225 can experience much more muscle growth and strength if these things happen- 2 or more seconds on the negative, strong contraction/squeeze at the top, controlling the weight, and FEELING THE MUSCLE WORK, (there may be a few more things so feel free to add to them)

you can get a better workout with a lighter weight AND MAKE THE MUSCLE WORK HARDER WITH THE LIGHTER WEIGHT,

if the person doing the 275 starts to perform the same as the 225 guy then obviously the person doing 275 will have a better workout....

you get my point


Strange? I don't recall making any comment about technique in my initial post....although, you are not going to be able to find any posts by me recommending someone use poor technique on an exercise in order to lift heavier weight.

So basically, your point has absolutly no relevance to what I said.


In short...do more work. Put more weight on the bar, do more reps than last time, etc.....For the general trainee keep it simple (read Beyond Braun by Stuart McRoberts or Super Squats by Strossen....simple programs...do more work). Unless you are looking to compete in something specific and have a need to really really plan training, then keep it simple.

you get my point?



Posted by: swordfish

i never said that you advocated bad form, but people would continue to put weight on the bar as you said and their form would probably decrease. just making the point to people that dont know, the absolute weight on the bar does not always matter.



Posted by: swordfish

Quote:
Originally Posted by ForemanRules View Post
I don't think anyone gets your point.
noone usually gets your point either.



Posted by: P-funk

Quote:
Originally Posted by swordfish View Post
i never said that you advocated bad form, but people would continue to put weight on the bar as you said and their form would probably decrease. just making the point to people that dont know, the absolute weight on the bar does not always matter.
good point.


edit:

add weight to the bar ONLY if form is good.



I sometimes take it for granted that people would use common sense with things like this.



Posted by: TJ Cline

Quote:
Originally Posted by swordfish View Post
noone usually gets your point either.
Very true, most here are beneath my intelligence.








bodybuilding diet | bodybuilding workouts | bodybuilding supplements | muscle building | burn body fat | build muscle




vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.


Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.1.0

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36