IronMagazine Bodybuilding Forums


IronMagLabs - Bodybuilding Supplements
Pages: 1

Are fruits and veggies necessary for optimal health?

(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)




Posted by: Stewart14

Let's say you eat a clean diet with good ratios of carbs, proteins and fats, and take a multi vitamin every day. By clean I mean you eat brown rice, sweet potatoes, chicken, lean beef, turkey, cheerios, eggs, milk, etc. Are you getting all you need from these foods and the multi, or are you missing something?

I understand you eat veggies and fruits to get the vitamins from them, as well as being assured you are eating foods that are "good for you", but let's say you don't really eat them daily, does the vitamin assure you get what you need, vitamin wise?



Posted by: Skib

lmao! cheerios?



Posted by: IronAddict

You'll get more vitamins from the actual foods, then you would from the supps. The supps are just to add what you may be missing. A well balanced diet is your best bet.



Posted by: fufu

Fiber is a big reason.



Posted by: Ben dur

i started eating more fruit, and not counting the cals...
(banana, kiwi, mango, peach, apple)-my favs-
still consuming maint elsewhere


i crushed all of my personal records in a matter of a couple weeks
and my body composition improved


there is no replacement



Posted by: KelJu

Veggies are necessary for me, mainly for the health of my butthole. The fiber makes keeps my poo the right consistency so that I onyl have to go once or twice a day.

Also, there are lots of vitamins and minerals that you get from fresh stemmed veggies that you can't get in supps.



Posted by: Ben dur

agreed

steamed veggies/garden salad with at least 3 meals a day for me


and i generally dont count these cals either



Posted by: AKIRA

I eat bananas, blueberries, strawberries, watermelon, meh..thats about it.

Veggies? Shit, broccoli is easy, but asparagus still puts up a fight. Spinach was mentioned to me. It was suggested to replace lettuce in my subs with fresh spinach leaves. Dont know what this will do, so some insight is needed.

What about cooked spinach?



Posted by: Ben dur

do the nutritional facts of raw veggies change after they are steamed?
should i be counting these calories?

if so this throws a real wrench at me, i dont even measure them... i just indulge



Posted by: JailHouse

Quote:
Originally Posted by AKIRA View Post
I eat bananas, blueberries, strawberries, watermelon, meh..thats about it.

Veggies? Shit, broccoli is easy, but asparagus still puts up a fight. Spinach was mentioned to me. It was suggested to replace lettuce in my subs with fresh spinach leaves. Dont know what this will do, so some insight is needed.

What about cooked spinach?
I usually eat a turkey sandwich at work and I use spinach in it. Its a easy way to get in some veggies while your at work and it taste about the same as lettuce.



Posted by: KelJu

Quote:
Originally Posted by AKIRA View Post
I eat bananas, blueberries, strawberries, watermelon, meh..thats about it.

Veggies? Shit, broccoli is easy, but asparagus still puts up a fight. Spinach was mentioned to me. It was suggested to replace lettuce in my subs with fresh spinach leaves. Dont know what this will do, so some insight is needed.

What about cooked spinach?
You have to steam asparagus for a long time. It helps.



Posted by: JailHouse

Quote:
Originally Posted by KelJu View Post
You have to steam asparagus for a long time. It helps.
Why not grill it?



Posted by: KelJu

Quote:
Originally Posted by JailHouse View Post
Why not grill it?
I don't have a grill right now.



Posted by: P-funk

I think that vegetables and fruit are vital to a diet. they give us vitamins, minerals, phytonutrients/antioxidants and fiber. they are extremely nutritious and i think you are missing out by not incorporating them.
Quote:
lmao! cheerios?
What the hell is wrong with cheerios? They aren't awful and you can easily figure them into your diet. I hate bodybuilding voodo.



Posted by: Skib

Quote:
Originally Posted by P-funk View Post
What the hell is wrong with cheerios? They aren't awful and you can easily figure them into your diet. I hate bodybuilding voodo.
haha i know, believe me, if there's anyone who loves their cereal, it's me...

it just looked funny in that list of food... totally random...



Posted by: x superman

No matter how many vitamines and fibers you are taking in your diet I think that fruit and veggies are essential for healthy diet.



Posted by: VanessaNicole

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stewart20 View Post
Let's say you eat a clean diet with good ratios of carbs, proteins and fats, and take a multi vitamin every day. By clean I mean you eat brown rice, sweet potatoes, chicken, lean beef, turkey, cheerios, eggs, milk, etc. Are you getting all you need from these foods and the multi, or are you missing something?

I understand you eat veggies and fruits to get the vitamins from them, as well as being assured you are eating foods that are "good for you", but let's say you don't really eat them daily, does the vitamin assure you get what you need, vitamin wise?
Yes.

And vitamins are not the only thing your body needs from fruit and vegetables.

I don't even have the energy to explain this at the moment.

You will eventually be all kind of sick if you do not consume adequate fruit and vegetables.

That is all.



Posted by: seems

Thats one good question. Yeah I think natural foods are most effective than supplements.



Posted by: KentDog

Keeping this comment separate from the "real food over supplements" argument in which we all agree real food > supplements, I do not feel you need to consume fruits and veggies daily to be in spectacular health. Often times when I budget myself for food costwise, I don't eat a lot of fruits or veggies.

I am thinking back to a few years ago when I was in the best shape of my life, and I do not recall eating hardly any vegatables but did eat the occassional apple or pear. I am getting back into pretty good shape now and I rarely eat fruits or vegetables.

Care to explain why fruits and vegetables are so "essential" or "vital" to a healthy diet? And how much are we talking about? If I rarely eat fruits or vegetables, are you saying that my diet is not "healthy?" I can run a 7-minute mile with no problem and box five three-minute rounds without gassing out. I have kept my strength up in the gym with no decline while cutting/maintaining. I feel very healthy.



Posted by: Gazhole

Quote:
Originally Posted by AKIRA View Post
What about cooked spinach?
Cooked spinach is one of my favourite additions to a lot of meals. If im sauteing (spell?) some potatoes ill throw in some spinach to give it a bit of colour and flavour. Only takes like 2 minutes to wilt, and you're away.

But yeah, i dont think i could go a day without fruit and veg. Maybe one of the other, but not both. Just because i love them, any health bonuses are...well, bonuses.

Im not taking a multivit atm either, so for the time being i need them for that aswell.



Posted by: FishOrCutBait

Quote:
Originally Posted by KentDog View Post
Keeping this comment separate from the "real food over supplements" argument in which we all agree real food > supplements, I do not feel you need to consume fruits and veggies daily to be in spectacular health. Often times when I budget myself for food costwise, I don't eat a lot of fruits or veggies.

I am thinking back to a few years ago when I was in the best shape of my life, and I do not recall eating hardly any vegatables but did eat the occassional apple or pear. I am getting back into pretty good shape now and I rarely eat fruits or vegetables.

Care to explain why fruits and vegetables are so "essential" or "vital" to a healthy diet? And how much are we talking about? If I rarely eat fruits or vegetables, are you saying that my diet is not "healthy?" I can run a 7-minute mile with no problem and box five three-minute rounds without gassing out. I have kept my strength up in the gym with no decline while cutting/maintaining. I feel very healthy.
I think its mostly for the long term health benefits, i.e. the stuff from the phytonutrients, and from the dietary supplementation they give you, like the fiber and the different vitamins.

I take a fiber supplement and a great multi, haha. just starting having a cup of mixed frozen berries in my pre-bed shake though and mmmmmm.

apples are pretty easy too.



Posted by: Stewart14

Quote:
Originally Posted by KentDog View Post
Keeping this comment separate from the "real food over supplements" argument in which we all agree real food > supplements, I do not feel you need to consume fruits and veggies daily to be in spectacular health. Often times when I budget myself for food costwise, I don't eat a lot of fruits or veggies.

I am thinking back to a few years ago when I was in the best shape of my life, and I do not recall eating hardly any vegatables but did eat the occassional apple or pear. I am getting back into pretty good shape now and I rarely eat fruits or vegetables.

Care to explain why fruits and vegetables are so "essential" or "vital" to a healthy diet? And how much are we talking about? If I rarely eat fruits or vegetables, are you saying that my diet is not "healthy?" I can run a 7-minute mile with no problem and box five three-minute rounds without gassing out. I have kept my strength up in the gym with no decline while cutting/maintaining. I feel very healthy.
Thank you for adding this. this is pretty much what I wanted to say in creating this post. I mean, I am not entirely pleased with my diet not containing much of the fruit and veggie group, but on the whole, my diet is generally real good in terms of clean foods. I am more concerned with getting proper amounts of good carbs, proteins, and good fats, as opposed to where they come from.

I can see how veggies can be a tool if you are looking to cut or suppress appetite, but as far as the nutrients go, yes I am sure eating veggies and fruits to get the vitamins from them is better than taking a vitamin, but still, how much and how many veggies would you really need to eat to get the same amounts of each nutrient in a good multi vitamin?



Posted by: Merkaba

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stewart20 View Post
Thank you for adding this. this is pretty much what I wanted to say in creating this post. I mean, I am not entirely pleased with my diet not containing much of the fruit and veggie group, but on the whole, my diet is generally real good in terms of clean foods. I am more concerned with getting proper amounts of good carbs, proteins, and good fats, as opposed to where they come from.

I can see how veggies can be a tool if you are looking to cut or suppress appetite, but as far as the nutrients go, yes I am sure eating veggies and fruits to get the vitamins from them is better than taking a vitamin, but still, how much and how many veggies would you really need to eat to get the same amounts of each nutrient in a good multi vitamin?
Well for one, how much of that rock of a vitamin is your body absorbing?
Plus there are other things like phytonutrients and enzymes that youre getting, not to mention the fiber. You might feel great.
But how do you know youre not harboring a growing tumor in your gut or another impending disease? We all know that veggies and fruits have way more benefits than Centrum or GNC vitamins

Quote:
Originally Posted by AKIRA View Post
I eat bananas, blueberries, strawberries, watermelon, meh..thats about it.

Veggies? Shit, broccoli is easy, but asparagus still puts up a fight. Spinach was mentioned to me. It was suggested to replace lettuce in my subs with fresh spinach leaves. Dont know what this will do, so some insight is needed.

What about cooked spinach?
Well because one spinach leaf has about twice the nutritional value of a head iceberg lettuce. (not literally but iceberg has little nutrition)



Posted by: Stewart14

Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkaba View Post
Well for one, how much of that rock of a vitamin is your body absorbing?
Plus there are other things like phytonutrients and enzymes that youre getting, not to mention the fiber. You might feel great.
But how do you know youre not harboring a growing tumor in your gut or another impending disease? We all know that veggies and fruits have way more benefits than Centrum or GNC vitamins



Well because one spinach leaf has about twice the nutritional value of a head iceberg lettuce. (not literally but iceberg has little nutrition)
I was talking about having a clean diet that lacks large amounts of veggies. I was not referring to someone who eats mcdonalds every day and no veggies. I dont think the lack of veggies in my diet would be a contributing cause to a tumor, come on now. I am sure there are plenty of fanatics out there who all they eat are veggies and fruit and they get sick too. I dont think my cheerios and turkey chili is going to kill me.

no one really touched on exactly how much nutrition are in fruits and veggies. For example, how many oranges would you need to eat to get the same amount of vitamin c in one 1000 mg capsule? Or how many carrots would you need to eat to get the amount of vitamin a in a multi vitamin? i know i am sure almost everyone on this board takes a good multi vitamin, so besides being just real good for you, what is the difference between a snack of carrots or a snack of oatmeal?

and what is a phytonutrient?



Posted by: fufu

Regardless of fruit being nessecary for optimal health, don't you like eating it anyway? I personally love fruit. Would you see it as a task to consume it?



Posted by: Stewart14

Quote:
Originally Posted by fufu View Post
Regardless of fruit being nessecary for optimal health, don't you like eating it anyway? I personally love fruit. Would you see it as a task to consume it?
Oh I love fruit, don't get me wrong. I think my original point was to ask if it is necessary to have x amount of fruit and vegetables daily to have optimum health benefits, or can you go a couple days without them, then have some here and there, etc. I just find it expensive to find good fruit around me, and now that my son is starting to eat stuff like this too, it gets to be a lot, and if I could only serve one of us, he is getting the good stuff.

I am trying to get better, I am starting to incorporate at least one piece of fruit and some type of vegetable daily. Unfortunately, my selection for vegetables right now consists of potatoes, sweet potatoes, corn and beans. Fruit is an apple or banana.

A good start?



Posted by: Will Brink

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stewart20 View Post
, does the vitamin assure you get what you need, vitamin wise?
No.



Posted by: Ben dur

im still pretty lost



Posted by: steelhorse

yes I think veggys are important to keep your system regular





Posted by: BabySteps

Quote:
Originally Posted by KentDog View Post
Keeping this comment separate from the "real food over supplements" argument in which we all agree real food > supplements, I do not feel you need to consume fruits and veggies daily to be in spectacular health. Often times when I budget myself for food costwise, I don't eat a lot of fruits or veggies.

I am thinking back to a few years ago when I was in the best shape of my life, and I do not recall eating hardly any vegatables but did eat the occassional apple or pear. I am getting back into pretty good shape now and I rarely eat fruits or vegetables.

Care to explain why fruits and vegetables are so "essential" or "vital" to a healthy diet? And how much are we talking about? If I rarely eat fruits or vegetables, are you saying that my diet is not "healthy?" I can run a 7-minute mile with no problem and box five three-minute rounds without gassing out. I have kept my strength up in the gym with no decline while cutting/maintaining. I feel very healthy.
Understood, but...

First of all, how old are you? Hell, anyone can be in great shape when they're young enough. How many of us could eat anything we wanted and never gain a pound and have endless energy when we were young?

Second, just because you feel OK today and have energy doesn't mean that lack of fruits and vegetables will not have a negative impact on your body down the road. Like it or not, fruits and vegies have been proven over and over to repair cells, fight disease, etc. Why do you think most diseases appear in middle age? Years of neglecting to eat right and exercise. Just a thought...



Posted by: Merkaba

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stewart20 View Post
Oh I love fruit, don't get me wrong. I think my original point was to ask if it is necessary to have x amount of fruit and vegetables daily to have optimum health benefits, or can you go a couple days without them, then have some here and there, etc. I just find it expensive to find good fruit around me, and now that my son is starting to eat stuff like this too, it gets to be a lot, and if I could only serve one of us, he is getting the good stuff.

I am trying to get better, I am starting to incorporate at least one piece of fruit and some type of vegetable daily. Unfortunately, my selection for vegetables right now consists of potatoes, sweet potatoes, corn and beans. Fruit is an apple or banana.

A good start?
Phytonutrients

I think this is one of those situations that doesnt have an answer. Whats the question is there a certain amount of fruits and veggies we should eat? I don't think we can eat enough veggies. But mentioning cost as a deterrant sheds more light on the situation. Potatoes corn and beans is alot of starch in my yes...but better than non at all indeed. I think one could write a book on broccoli and spinach and other leafy veggies though. If you read about them you will want to include them in every meal. I agree it does get expensive and you just have to do what you can. I get a big bag of broccoli florets from sams for like 5 bucks. The equivalent would cost me 20 bucks in the supermarket. I'm actually eating a bowl of cooked broccoli now! I dont eat veggies with every meal but I really try nowadays. My grandad just got a colostomy bag yesterday due to a rectal cancerous mass resulting in removal of part of his rectum. I don't have specific statistics but I've read how digestive cancers are more prevalent. Hey, will shoving copious amounts of fibrous greens keep me from getting the same, who knows, but I know I've tried one aspect of prevention, among others.

And of course with kids its taste. try various recipes and veggies to try to get them to eat more stuff. I used to hate broccoli and okra. Now I don't love broccoli but I can eat it and almost ignore it, but okra I can eat by the pound. My girlfriends little three year old niece somehow loves "bocky" and "zukenny". If thats your kid in the avatar my girlfriend and i were talking about how cute he is.



Posted by: KentDog

Quote:
Originally Posted by BabySteps View Post
Understood, but...

First of all, how old are you? Hell, anyone can be in great shape when they're young enough. How many of us could eat anything we wanted and never gain a pound and have endless energy when we were young?

Second, just because you feel OK today and have energy doesn't mean that lack of fruits and vegetables will not have a negative impact on your body down the road. Like it or not, fruits and vegies have been proven over and over to repair cells, fight disease, etc. Why do you think most diseases appear in middle age? Years of neglecting to eat right and exercise. Just a thought...
Good points and something to think about. Though I'm not one of those who can eat whatever I wanted and not gain a pound, I do agree that there is extensive research out there supporting various health benefits of consuming fruits and vegetables.

To answer your question, I'm 23. The main thing I question is similar to what I think Stewart is asking, and that is whether the same health benefits of fruits and veggies can be obtained from a clean diet w/ good amounts of p/c/f along with basic supplement usage (multivitamin, fish oils, and whey protein) without eating fruits and vegetables regularly. I don't believe there are studies out there that nail the question of optimal amount (afterall, they need to be balanced in your diet as well; you add in calories from fruits and veggies and you must subtract from other foods, with the exception of no calories veggies).



Posted by: KentDog

Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkaba View Post
Phytonutrients

I think this is one of those situations that doesnt have an answer. Whats the question is there a certain amount of fruits and veggies we should eat? I don't think we can eat enough veggies. But mentioning cost as a deterrant sheds more light on the situation. Potatoes corn and beans is alot of starch in my yes...but better than non at all indeed. I think one could write a book on broccoli and spinach and other leafy veggies though. If you read about them you will want to include them in every meal. I agree it does get expensive and you just have to do what you can. I get a big bag of broccoli florets from sams for like 5 bucks. The equivalent would cost me 20 bucks in the supermarket. I'm actually eating a bowl of cooked broccoli now! I dont eat veggies with every meal but I really try nowadays. My grandad just got a colostomy bag yesterday due to a rectal cancerous mass resulting in removal of part of his rectum. I don't have specific statistics but I've read how digestive cancers are more prevalent. Hey, will shoving copious amounts of fibrous greens keep me from getting the same, who knows, but I know I've tried one aspect of prevention, among others.
Great post.



Posted by: Merkaba

Quote:
Originally Posted by KentDog View Post
Good points and something to think about. Though I'm not one of those who can eat whatever I wanted and not gain a pound, I do agree that there is extensive research out there supporting various health benefits of consuming fruits and vegetables.

To answer your question, I'm 23. The main thing I question is similar to what I think Stewart is asking, and that is whether the same health benefits of fruits and veggies can be obtained from a clean diet w/ good amounts of p/c/f along with basic supplement usage (multivitamin, fish oils, and whey protein) without eating fruits and vegetables regularly. I don't believe there are studies out there that nail the question of optimal amount (afterall, they need to be balanced in your diet as well; you add in calories from fruits and veggies and you must subtract from other foods, with the exception of no calories veggies).

Remember we are made to be VERY active and carry decent amounts of fat. I think most would agree. Enough to where a few hundred calories a day in fruits would be a non issue. Plus I would be willing to bet that you could find a ton of studies touting the benefits of the fiber alone in veggies and fruits. Gotta have something helping to move the crap out of your system. How many studies talk about the crap that sits in your digestive walls. Gotta have that fiber!



Posted by: Ben dur

like i said before

adding in fruit to my maint. diet did nothing to my body fat, if not lower it

it did however give me a substantially greater amount of energy and drive in and out of the gym

the result was a more viperous and active Ben, burning more calories daily, and lifting more weight in the gym



Posted by: Witchblade

Fruits and veggies are still calories. Period. The thermogenic effect is often negligible.



Posted by: mike1989

ofcourse the fruits and vegetables are important. when you are on a diet the vegetables and fruits provide you vitamins and minerals.



Posted by: BabySteps

Quote:
Originally Posted by KentDog View Post
Good points and something to think about. Though I'm not one of those who can eat whatever I wanted and not gain a pound, I do agree that there is extensive research out there supporting various health benefits of consuming fruits and vegetables.

To answer your question, I'm 23. The main thing I question is similar to what I think Stewart is asking, and that is whether the same health benefits of fruits and veggies can be obtained from a clean diet w/ good amounts of p/c/f along with basic supplement usage (multivitamin, fish oils, and whey protein) without eating fruits and vegetables regularly. I don't believe there are studies out there that nail the question of optimal amount (afterall, they need to be balanced in your diet as well; you add in calories from fruits and veggies and you must subtract from other foods, with the exception of no calories veggies).

Oh to be 23 again... I guess my confusion is this: a clean diet is one that includes a substantial amount of fruits and vegies in addition to lean meats, whole grains and low fat dairy. I do understand your question, though, and I think you have a valid question. With the advances in supplements to include probiotics and phytonutrients, who's to say if we really need to eat lots of fruit and vegies? That would be an interesting study. I eat clean, but it's hard for me to get in the amount of protein I need AND eat the fruits and vegies on top of it--I'm just too full or I don't have the calories to spare. To remedy this, I eat grapes with every meal (not a lot, though), I have tomatoes and a variety of nuts as a snack (which I found that nuts have a lots of the same healthful benefits as fruits/vegies), and I have at least one serving of vegies with my lean protein for dinner. All in all, I think we'd all be interested in knowing the answer to this question. I'll keep researching this one, as I've always been interested in nutrition. I'll keep you posted!



Posted by: mike1989

yes they are very important to provide minerals and vitamins to your body.



Posted by: marcuz29

I am thankful to find this post. Got lots of knowledge and ideas from this thread.



Posted by: Stewart14

Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkaba View Post
Phytonutrients

I think this is one of those situations that doesnt have an answer. Whats the question is there a certain amount of fruits and veggies we should eat? I don't think we can eat enough veggies. But mentioning cost as a deterrant sheds more light on the situation. Potatoes corn and beans is alot of starch in my yes...but better than non at all indeed. I think one could write a book on broccoli and spinach and other leafy veggies though. If you read about them you will want to include them in every meal. I agree it does get expensive and you just have to do what you can. I get a big bag of broccoli florets from sams for like 5 bucks. The equivalent would cost me 20 bucks in the supermarket. I'm actually eating a bowl of cooked broccoli now! I dont eat veggies with every meal but I really try nowadays. My grandad just got a colostomy bag yesterday due to a rectal cancerous mass resulting in removal of part of his rectum. I don't have specific statistics but I've read how digestive cancers are more prevalent. Hey, will shoving copious amounts of fibrous greens keep me from getting the same, who knows, but I know I've tried one aspect of prevention, among others.

And of course with kids its taste. try various recipes and veggies to try to get them to eat more stuff. I used to hate broccoli and okra. Now I don't love broccoli but I can eat it and almost ignore it, but okra I can eat by the pound. My girlfriends little three year old niece somehow loves "bocky" and "zukenny". If thats your kid in the avatar my girlfriend and i were talking about how cute he is.
Thanks, this was a good post.

and yes, that is my son, thanks for the compliment The boy can eat 800 bananas a day, but not touch anything else in the fruit or veggie department



Posted by: Merkaba

haha.....I like bananas but not that much. When I was in college I would get them from the lunch bar and eat two or three a day religiously. I swear 99% of my farts never smelt! i think it had something to do with the bananas. Cause after I graduated and stopped eating them as much it was back to the same old same old killer gas.



Posted by: Ben dur

bananas are my #1 favorite food



Posted by: BabySteps

Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkaba View Post
haha.....I like bananas but not that much. When I was in college I would get them from the lunch bar and eat two or three a day religiously. I swear 99% of my farts never smelt! i think it had something to do with the bananas. Cause after I graduated and stopped eating them as much it was back to the same old same old killer gas.
You crack me up!!!



Posted by: min0 lee

Quote:
Originally Posted by Merkaba View Post
haha.....I like bananas but not that much. When I was in college I would get them from the lunch bar and eat two or three a day religiously. I swear 99% of my farts never smelt! i think it had something to do with the bananas. Cause after I graduated and stopped eating them as much it was back to the same old same old killer gas.
Bananas do the same for me also..



Posted by: Merkaba

Quote:
Originally Posted by min0 lee View Post
Bananas do the same for me also..
seriously?



Posted by: min0 lee

Yes.



Posted by: mike1989

i bananas too



Posted by: FishOrCutBait

Quote:
Originally Posted by mike1989 View Post
i bananas too




(CLICK HERE here to view the original thread with full colors/images)

Are fruits and veggies necessary for optimal health?


Article Archives

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60