Thread: Good consealable revolver/semi-auto

titanium taurus .38

Maybe a thunder five if you need to really clear the corner.

Most revolvers don't have safeties. Something like a .357 mag would be nice. Plenty of power for self defense and can shoot .38 special which is easier on the wallet and wrist. I'm not a revolver fan myself though.

Ruger Lcp is a nice pocket gun

I've got the Taurus .357 mag and love it! It has the key saftey in the hammer or u can get a hammerless pocket safe model

44 automag

The judge.

Originally Posted by colochine

The judge.

The judge is fine but not a pocket pistol.
45lc/.410 shotgun shells
It will clear a room

I like my S&W MP .45. Got laser sight for the tactical rail. As far as revolvers... I've been looking to get a snub nose .357. Not sure what brand though.

Ruger LCR in .357 magnum flavor. Pocket revolver with big gun bang.

In my opinion, it all depends on what your needing it for. Not many people these days use wheel guns as a primary concealed... but then, a firearm is a very personal decision.

Taurus makes some inexpensive revolvers. The_model_850 is very a compact and concealable .38 Special. Personally, I'd use it more as a back up rather than anything else.

I wouldn't recommend a .357Mag Snubby. You'll beat your hands black & blue. if you ever do any serious range shooting with it.

Another vote for the Ruger LCR. I agree with Witmaster that it wouldn't be very fun to shoot full power magnum loads very often but, for self defense, it can't be beat.

If you wouldn't mind the extra weight, you can get the same gun in a heavier package in an SP-101.

Glock 25 or 28

Originally Posted by Dark Geared God

44 automag

Easily concealed LOL

My all time light duty carry gun S@W Scandium Airlite PD hammerless 5 shot .357 mag
11 ounces empty. .357 plenty of power.

A little more Kimber UDP 3" .40 cal with two back up mags 23 onces empty

Full house carry .45 1911 no doubt weight not a consideration

.357 concealed



Di Santi Holster very comfy


Scandium S&W .357

Originally Posted by Witmaster

In my opinion, it all depends on what your needing it for. Not many people these days use wheel guns as a primary concealed... but then, a firearm is a very personal decision.

Taurus makes some inexpensive revolvers. The_model_850 is very a compact and concealable .38 Special. Personally, I'd use it more as a back up rather than anything else.

I wouldn't recommend a .357Mag Snubby. You'll beat your hands black & blue. if you ever do any serious range shooting with it.

Practice with .38's. CARRY .357's, IF and when you NEED the gun you won't feel the recoil anyway.

I find that my 11oz .357 is fine to shoot with .357 for about 10 - 15 rounds. Then yes it begins to make me flintch, I agree with Witmaster
I can shoot is all day with .38's. I also shoot competition.

Imho, a revolver makes for a cumbersome pocket gun because of the imprinting issues. .380 +p loads will do the trick... no need for a magnum round.

Originally Posted by meow

Imho, a revolver makes for a cumbersome pocket gun because of the imprinting issues. .380 +p loads will do the trick... no need for a magnum round.

Pocket holster helps too. But I don't like the pocket holsters speed and sometimes they don;t stay in your pocket. cannot rely on sometimes!

That is why I carry on the belt.

Also I would rather someone who is NOT proficient in gun handling to carry a hammerless wheel gun no safety no brains the original point and click interface.

I used to sell guns and EVERYONE wants an Semi Auto. I can tell you most people just don't shoot enought to be proficient in clearing jams, reloading of even getting a round chambered, let alone remember to flip the safety. Then they THINK they can get a round on target?? HA

I carry my .40 and .45 in condition 1, cocked and locked. But it scare me to think about people having an AD with a semi.

I like the revolver for the simplicity no brains in a high stess environment.

Look for a single stack compact pistol. In that price range you can get a LCP and still have money to get a bunch of ammo and a holster. I've had nearly all of the pocket guns and these are my two top picks. Sorry but they are out of your price range.

Colt Mustang .380 (They just started making these again)
&
Colt New Agent .45


I would really recommend picking up something like these. I CANNOT stand the heavy ass double action only trigger of the other .380's. They are too small and with that trigger pull it makes you shoot to the left.

Make a "gun" with you pointer finger and thumb. Now pull the pointer finger back with the rest of your fist. See how your hand rolled in when you closed it? Well these pocket pistols (LCP, Bodyguard) have such a long, hard trigger that you practically have to close your hand on it.

Anything with a single action trigger is much nicer. With that being said, I could shoot my LCP better than my S&W Bodyguard.

How are you planning to carry it? IMO if it's going to be on you then comfort is #1. I'd rather have a .22 that I carry every day than a .45 that I carry once a week. The little .380s are perfect in terms of concealability. Get a DeSantis Nemisis pocket holster like the one underneath my mustang. You can carry it in your pocket and it looks like a wallet. It's made to snag on your pocket when you pull the gun out which releases the gun and leaves the holster. I really like mine.

If you just want to leave it in your car, then you have more options. Personally I'd stick to a 1911 body type but a glock or a M&P or a XD would be good options. You can get them for around 400 used. Also take into account how much ammo costs and availablity.

Originally Posted by SloppyJ

How are you planning to carry it? IMO if it's going to be on you then comfort is #1. I'd rather have a .22 that I carry every day than a .45 that I carry once a week. .

indeed! There is good validity to 10-12 .22 shots in the chest too.



One of the reasons I carry the 11 oz. S&W is is a good balance between comfort and stopping power. But the S&W misses the mark on price!
I own a few Colts and several 1911 style pistols and love them all!

Originally Posted by jagbender

indeed! There is good validity to 10-12 .22 shots in the chest too.

One of the reasons I carry the 11 oz. S&W is is a good balance between comfort and stopping power. But the S&W misses the mark on price!
I own a few Colts and several 1911 style pistols and love them all!

I've had pretty much every type of pistol. I spent years with the plastic pistols trying to get one that I liked. I finally tried a 1911 and I never looked back.

I think my next purchase will be a Browning Buckmark .22 or a Ruger Mark Series .22. I want something that is cheap to shoot and something that my GF isn't scared of.

Originally Posted by SloppyJ

I've had pretty much every type of pistol. I spent years with the plastic pistols trying to get one that I liked. I finally tried a 1911 and I never looked back.

I think my next purchase will be a Browning Buckmark .22 or a Ruger Mark Series .22. I want something that is cheap to shoot and something that my GF isn't scared of.

I have owned both
Thumbs down on the Buckmark

I shoot Bullseye and shoot a Pardini SP.
Also had IZH 35 M It was a decent shooter for the money
I started with several Rugers. One you get a trigger job they do shoot very well. You might like the 22/45 because of the simililairity to the 1911 feel. Volquartzen makes many aftermarket parts for the Rugers.
Trigger and grips ETC.

Originally Posted by jagbender

I have owned both
Thumbs down on the Buckmark

I shoot Bullseye and shoot a Pardini SP.
Also had IZH 35 M It was a decent shooter for the money
I started with several Rugers. One you get a trigger job they do shoot very well. You might like the 22/45 because of the simililairity to the 1911 feel. Volquartzen makes many aftermarket parts for the Rugers.
Trigger and grips ETC.

PM'd so we stay on topic in here.

Well my gift is a surprise now so im not sure its a pistol (maybe it is) but I think im going to get some night sights on my ccw. It goes with me everywhere, if its not on my hip its in the car. I love being able to carry, I feel so much safer for myself and family. You never know when some crazy person may approach you.

Chances are you're not going to use the sights if something happens. This is why it's important to practice point shooting.

Night sights are cool and all but in reality you won't be able to see your sights @ night after the first shot, because of the muzzle blast.
thumbs up to smaller calibers and non magnums.

But remember most defensive shooting will be at very close range and it is Imperitive that you shoot instinctivly. Practice practice and practice. Also if you have / or get a semi auto make sure you practice jam clearing and reloading mags. ALL of defensive shooting HAS to be instinctive. You MAY and should not have time to think about what to do. If you have time to think about what to do you probably don't have a legal right to protect yourself. MOST all laws say it needs to be a LAST option.

Of course there are scenarious when you may get kidnapped etc and DO have time to think. But statistically you need to expect the unexpected. Only training does that, It makes your response automatic and helps keep you out of prison.
Just my .02