Thread: ON Whey Protein VS Dynamatize Elite

dymatize is what i use to use now i use scivation. for taste wise between your two i would go with dymatize.

I like ON.

never really used anything else aside from atw a couple times

the cheapest i can find. right now its allthewhey.com or sbmuscle.com

I don't know about the taste, but protein wise, ON is better than Dymatyze. ON has whey isolate as a main source of protein, while Dymatyze has whey concentrate as main source of protein. I think whey isolate is considered better than whey concentrate.
Just my opinion.

I have always used ON but agree on what ever is cheapest.

I am more partial to using quality supplements and don't think that using the cheapest of anything is the best method of choosing your brands.

Sounds good guys keep the suggestions coming.

Originally Posted by Prince

I am more partial to using quality supplements and don't think that using the cheapest of anything is the best method of choosing your brands.

if i owned my own supplement company i would use pure isolate as well

i eat so much protein from food, that i doubt using a blend will make that much of a difference. vitamins on the other hand..

I have used a few different types of Protein but once I went with ON I never went back to anything else. It is fairly cheap, it tastes good, and it is isolate. To me that is the triple threat of perfection. I like ON and will stay with it. They have such a wide variety of flavors that you can always order something new to mix it up.

I did just order my first batch of Cesine protein. I have never taken it before, but I have been reading about it and decided I would give it a try. Double Rich Chocolate for the Whey and Creamy Vanilla for the Cesine. I am excited

Both of these would suffice very well.

Originally Posted by chobby192

I don't know about the taste, but protein wise, ON is better than Dymatyze. ON has whey isolate as a main source of protein, while Dymatyze has whey concentrate as main source of protein. I think whey isolate is considered better than whey concentrate.
Just my opinion.

I cold be wrong, I have to check the label n stuff when I get home, but I'm pretty sure you're wrong about dymatize's protein source.. Regardless, imho ON is WAY too sweet for my taste. Plus dymatize is much better for low carb low cal diets.. And its WAY cheaper.. Dymatize alll the way for me

Originally Posted by Cgrant

I cold be wrong, I have to check the label n stuff when I get home, but I'm pretty sure you're wrong about dymatize's protein source.. Regardless, imho ON is WAY too sweet for my taste. Plus dymatize is much better for low carb low cal diets.. And its WAY cheaper.. Dymatize alll the way for me

she is wrong..

dymatize
Other Ingredients: Ion-exchange whey protein isolates, cross flow ultra filtration whey protein concentrate (providing di-peptides, tri-peptides, oligo-peptides, and poly-peptides), whey peptides, cocoa, instant coffee, natural and artificial flavors and acesulfame-potassium.

optimum
Other Ingredients
Protein Blend(Whey Protein Isolate, Whey Protein Concentrate, Whey Peptides), Cocoa(Processed With Alkali), Artificial Flavor, Lecithin, Acesulfame Potassium

Originally Posted by PreMier

she is wrong..

dymatize
Other Ingredients: Ion-exchange whey protein isolates, cross flow ultra filtration whey protein concentrate (providing di-peptides, tri-peptides, oligo-peptides, and poly-peptides), whey peptides, cocoa, instant coffee, natural and artificial flavors and acesulfame-potassium.

optimum
Other Ingredients
Protein Blend(Whey Protein Isolate, Whey Protein Concentrate, Whey Peptides), Cocoa(Processed With Alkali), Artificial Flavor, Lecithin, Acesulfame Potassium

looks like they have basically the same ingredients, save for the instant coffee

Hey kinda off topic (sorry)
Does anyone know if sbmuscle.com ships to Canada?

Originally Posted by PreMier

if i owned my own supplement company i would use pure isolate as well

yes, whey isolate is expensive, but why not spend a little extra and get the best?

IronMagLabs Whey Isolate is only $19.99 for 2lbs if you buy 3 jugs. It's pure isolate, contains no extra crap and is sweetened with an herb (Stevia), it mixes very easily, and I think it tastes great. Whey Protein Isolate - 100% Pure

Originally Posted by FishOrCutBait

looks like they have basically the same ingredients, save for the instant coffee

thats because it was coffee flavored protein

Originally Posted by Prince

yes, whey isolate is expensive, but why not spend a little extra and get the best?

IronMagLabs Whey Isolate is only $19.99 for 2lbs if you buy 3 jugs. It's pure isolate, contains no extra crap and is sweetened with an herb (Stevia), it mixes very easily, and I think it tastes great. Whey Protein Isolate - 100% Pure

cuz im now a broke ass

but maybe i will next time i buy protein in a month. i have tried every other product

Originally Posted by PreMier

she is wrong..

Originally Posted by chobby192

what? you were i posted the ingredients.

you make a lot of statements

Originally Posted by PreMier

what? you were i posted the ingredients.

you make a lot of statements

ahh.. ok

feelings on their 12 hour blend? i happen to like it as my pre bed shake.. maybe thats just me hoping theyre right..

the best protein for night time imo (and nni will probably agree) is xtreme formulations ultra peptide. the protein fractions they use are pure undenatured low temp micellar casein

Sorry to muddy the waters.
Currently using Ironmag. It's great no complaints.

Question? How important is Isolate over a blend?
And why don't the 'blends' disclose percentages of isolate?

i just got a 5 lb jug of dymatize elite rich chocolate

cant say it tastes as good as ON cookies n creme.. but its certainly not the worst by any means

mixed with milk it is actually quite good

and the 5 lb jug cost me 30 bucks

whey proteine is much better, i tried both

anyone else feel like the ON is almost TOO generic after their recent label change?

not that it is a decision making factor, but i just liked it more before they changed it

Originally Posted by trener

whey proteine is much better, i tried both

can you please rephrase?

Originally Posted by jk7761

Sorry to muddy the waters.
Currently using Ironmag. It's great no complaints.

I agree. I noticed the label. It is 100% whey isolate. Like somenone mentioned somewhere, if you like protein blend, then mix it with milk.

And why don't the 'blends' disclose percentages of isolate?

For some reason they don't seem to disclose protein content of the blend. Only way to find out roughly how much each protein in the blend, is to look at ingredients. For ex: if ingredients look like this, Whey isolate, whey concentrate, then more isolate than concentrate. If it looks like, Whey concentrate, Whey isolate, then it has more whey concentrate than whey isolate.

how aboute Dymatize Elite against Ultimate pro star ,they are mix of isolate and concetrate,plus Dymatize have Enzyme blend -40mg