New Peril Tied to Steroid Abuse: Kidney Damage
By KATIE THOMAS
Published: December 9, 2009
Many competitive bodybuilders take anabolic steroids to achieve their freakishly exaggerated physiques. That is no secret. But steroids can be only one part of an extreme regimen that can wreak havoc on the body.
Joyce Dopkeen for The New York Times
Antonecchia has lost about 50 pounds and said he misses the attention his 290-pound frame attracted.
G
Gary Phillips
Kenneth Wheeler, a bodybuilder known as Flex, in 1996. He developed kidney disease and was forced to retire in 2003 at age 37.
Antonecchia competing in the 2001 New World Strongest Man competition where he was the runner-up.
Human growth hormone, supplements, painkillers and diuretics can also be used to create the ???shrink-wrapped??? muscles so prized in the aesthetic. And the high concentration of muscle mass puts stress on the body, as if the lifter were obese.
Lifting weights in the gym is ???extremely healthy for you,??? said Kenneth Wheeler, a former elite bodybuilder known as Flex. ???But if you want to be a bodybuilder and compete at the highest level, it has nothing to do with health.??? A relatively rare form of kidney disease forced Wheeler to retire in 2003 at age 37, and he needed a kidney transplant later that year.
Determining the extent of the damage that bodybuilders inflict on themselves is difficult, in part because there is little interest in financing studies on such an extreme group, and because bodybuilders are not always honest about what they take. That is why a case study published last month by a top kidney journal is generating interest in the nephrology and bodybuilding communities. It is among the first to assert a direct link between long-term steroid use and kidney disease.
The study began 10 years ago when a kidney pathologist at Columbia University Medical Center in New York noticed that a bodybuilder had an advanced form of kidney disease. Curious, she started looking for similar cases and eventually studied 10 men with serious kidney damage who acknowledged using steroids. Nine were bodybuilders and one was a competitive powerlifter with a similar training routine.
All 10 men in the case series, published in November by the Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, showed damage to the filters of the kidney. Nine had an irreversible disease known as focal segmental glomerulosclerosis ??? the same disease contracted by Wheeler ??? even though the men in the study did not have other apparent risk factors. Their disease was worse than in obese patients with a higher body-mass index, suggesting that steroids ??? combined with the other practices ??? might be harming the kidneys.
Among the study???s most persuasive details is the story of a man, 30 years old at the time, who damaged his kidneys after more than a decade of bodybuilding. The patient???s condition improved after he stopped using the drugs, discontinued his regimen and lost 80 pounds. But it worsened after the man, who became depressed, returned to bodybuilding and steroids.
???These patients are likely the tip of the iceberg,??? said Vivette D. D???Agati, the lead researcher. ???It???s a risk. A significant risk.???
Several experts not affiliated with the study said that while the claims were intriguing, the study???s value was limited because it focused only on intensive steroid users and because the bodybuilders??? layered training practices had to be taken into account. ???I think it???s hard to be certain what???s causing their kidney disease,??? said William Bremner, chairman of the Department of Medicine at the University of Washington and an endocrinologist who studies steroids.
D???Agati said, ???It???s probably multiple factors that are converging in these patients, but the common entity in all of them is anabolic steroids.???
One participant in the study, Patrick Antonecchia, 46, competed in powerlifting and strong man events for more than 25 years and said he used steroids, supplements and a high-protein diet to attain feats such as pulling a 40,000-pound truck. He ended his career and stopped using steroids about a year ago, and in February received a diagnosis of serious kidney damage. His doctors warned him not to use the drugs again. ???They said: ???Pat. Don???t. Because it comes back,??? ??? he said.
Antonecchia has lost about 50 pounds and said he misses the attention his 290-pound frame attracted: ???The toughest thing now is it was my identity for 25 years. Now, when people see me, they say. ???What happened to you???? ???
Jerry Brainum writes a column for Iron Man Magazine called Bodybuilding Pharmacology and said he welcomes more research on the subject. ???I found it very alarming, quite frankly,??? Brainum said.
Since the 1990s, at least eight accomplished bodybuilders have died at a young age, and in addition to Wheeler, another six were forced to stop competing because of serious illness, often involving kidney disease.
The main source of information for bodybuilders is word of mouth and experimentation, Brainum said. ???These guys have no guidance, they talk among themselves, and they don???t even tell the truth to each other,??? he said.
The risk-taking has been made worse by a trend toward ever larger physiques among the sport???s top competitors, some said. Jay Cutler, who won the 2009 Mr. Olympia contest, weighs almost 40 pounds more than Arnold Schwarzenegger did when he won the title in 1974, even though Cutler is five inches shorter.
???Each decade you have a guy that comes along that sets new standards and you say O.K., now I???m going to have to take it to the next level,??? said Shahriar Kamali, a professional bodybuilder known as King.
The International Federation of Body Building and Fitness reserves the right to test for steroids and human growth hormone at the professional level, and testing is done on a random basis, said Bob Cicherillo, athlete representative for the federation, which is the main governing body for bodybuilding.
But several bodybuilders said the testing was nearly nonexistent, and Cicherillo said he could not provide specific figures on competitors who tested positive. In addition, the chairman of the organization???s medical commission, Robert M. Goldman, is a leading champion of the anti-aging effects of human growth hormone, a drug that is banned by most sports governing bodies.
James Manion, who runs the professional division of the federation, did not return several calls seeking comment.
Some bodybuilders expressed doubt that their practices were dangerous, pointing to former competitors who are still healthy in their 70s. They attributed the deaths of elite bodybuilders to the abuse of over-the-counter painkillers and diuretics, not steroids. The bodybuilding federation tests for diuretics at professional events, although competitors said they are still used.
Bodybuilders said that they were unfairly singled out as drug abusers when athletes in most other sports were also using performance-enhancing drugs. ???Like anything else, it???s use and abuse,??? Cicherillo said. ???We???re the ones who are visual. We???re the ones who walk around, and you see us with the big muscles.???
Wheeler said he was convinced steroid use did not cause his kidney disease, although it might have made it worse.
The patient whose case was the centerpiece of the kidney study said he was most likely predisposed to develop the condition. ???The drugs weren???t the reason I got sick,??? said the man, who declined to be identified because his steroid use was illegal. After taking a year off from steroids and bodybuilding because of the kidney disease, the man, age 34, is returning to competition. His symptoms have worsened, a sacrifice he said he is willing to accept.
???It???s just really hard to walk away from it,??? he said. ???I know I can only do this until my early 40s, so I really want to give it my all now.???
By KATIE THOMAS
Published: December 9, 2009
Many competitive bodybuilders take anabolic steroids to achieve their freakishly exaggerated physiques. That is no secret. But steroids can be only one part of an extreme regimen that can wreak havoc on the body.
Joyce Dopkeen for The New York Times
Antonecchia has lost about 50 pounds and said he misses the attention his 290-pound frame attracted.
GGary Phillips
Kenneth Wheeler, a bodybuilder known as Flex, in 1996. He developed kidney disease and was forced to retire in 2003 at age 37.
Antonecchia competing in the 2001 New World Strongest Man competition where he was the runner-up.
Human growth hormone, supplements, painkillers and diuretics can also be used to create the ???shrink-wrapped??? muscles so prized in the aesthetic. And the high concentration of muscle mass puts stress on the body, as if the lifter were obese.
Lifting weights in the gym is ???extremely healthy for you,??? said Kenneth Wheeler, a former elite bodybuilder known as Flex. ???But if you want to be a bodybuilder and compete at the highest level, it has nothing to do with health.??? A relatively rare form of kidney disease forced Wheeler to retire in 2003 at age 37, and he needed a kidney transplant later that year.
Determining the extent of the damage that bodybuilders inflict on themselves is difficult, in part because there is little interest in financing studies on such an extreme group, and because bodybuilders are not always honest about what they take. That is why a case study published last month by a top kidney journal is generating interest in the nephrology and bodybuilding communities. It is among the first to assert a direct link between long-term steroid use and kidney disease.
The study began 10 years ago when a kidney pathologist at Columbia University Medical Center in New York noticed that a bodybuilder had an advanced form of kidney disease. Curious, she started looking for similar cases and eventually studied 10 men with serious kidney damage who acknowledged using steroids. Nine were bodybuilders and one was a competitive powerlifter with a similar training routine.
All 10 men in the case series, published in November by the Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, showed damage to the filters of the kidney. Nine had an irreversible disease known as focal segmental glomerulosclerosis ??? the same disease contracted by Wheeler ??? even though the men in the study did not have other apparent risk factors. Their disease was worse than in obese patients with a higher body-mass index, suggesting that steroids ??? combined with the other practices ??? might be harming the kidneys.
Among the study???s most persuasive details is the story of a man, 30 years old at the time, who damaged his kidneys after more than a decade of bodybuilding. The patient???s condition improved after he stopped using the drugs, discontinued his regimen and lost 80 pounds. But it worsened after the man, who became depressed, returned to bodybuilding and steroids.
???These patients are likely the tip of the iceberg,??? said Vivette D. D???Agati, the lead researcher. ???It???s a risk. A significant risk.???
Several experts not affiliated with the study said that while the claims were intriguing, the study???s value was limited because it focused only on intensive steroid users and because the bodybuilders??? layered training practices had to be taken into account. ???I think it???s hard to be certain what???s causing their kidney disease,??? said William Bremner, chairman of the Department of Medicine at the University of Washington and an endocrinologist who studies steroids.
D???Agati said, ???It???s probably multiple factors that are converging in these patients, but the common entity in all of them is anabolic steroids.???
One participant in the study, Patrick Antonecchia, 46, competed in powerlifting and strong man events for more than 25 years and said he used steroids, supplements and a high-protein diet to attain feats such as pulling a 40,000-pound truck. He ended his career and stopped using steroids about a year ago, and in February received a diagnosis of serious kidney damage. His doctors warned him not to use the drugs again. ???They said: ???Pat. Don???t. Because it comes back,??? ??? he said.
Antonecchia has lost about 50 pounds and said he misses the attention his 290-pound frame attracted: ???The toughest thing now is it was my identity for 25 years. Now, when people see me, they say. ???What happened to you???? ???
Jerry Brainum writes a column for Iron Man Magazine called Bodybuilding Pharmacology and said he welcomes more research on the subject. ???I found it very alarming, quite frankly,??? Brainum said.
Since the 1990s, at least eight accomplished bodybuilders have died at a young age, and in addition to Wheeler, another six were forced to stop competing because of serious illness, often involving kidney disease.
The main source of information for bodybuilders is word of mouth and experimentation, Brainum said. ???These guys have no guidance, they talk among themselves, and they don???t even tell the truth to each other,??? he said.
The risk-taking has been made worse by a trend toward ever larger physiques among the sport???s top competitors, some said. Jay Cutler, who won the 2009 Mr. Olympia contest, weighs almost 40 pounds more than Arnold Schwarzenegger did when he won the title in 1974, even though Cutler is five inches shorter.
???Each decade you have a guy that comes along that sets new standards and you say O.K., now I???m going to have to take it to the next level,??? said Shahriar Kamali, a professional bodybuilder known as King.
The International Federation of Body Building and Fitness reserves the right to test for steroids and human growth hormone at the professional level, and testing is done on a random basis, said Bob Cicherillo, athlete representative for the federation, which is the main governing body for bodybuilding.
But several bodybuilders said the testing was nearly nonexistent, and Cicherillo said he could not provide specific figures on competitors who tested positive. In addition, the chairman of the organization???s medical commission, Robert M. Goldman, is a leading champion of the anti-aging effects of human growth hormone, a drug that is banned by most sports governing bodies.
James Manion, who runs the professional division of the federation, did not return several calls seeking comment.
Some bodybuilders expressed doubt that their practices were dangerous, pointing to former competitors who are still healthy in their 70s. They attributed the deaths of elite bodybuilders to the abuse of over-the-counter painkillers and diuretics, not steroids. The bodybuilding federation tests for diuretics at professional events, although competitors said they are still used.
Bodybuilders said that they were unfairly singled out as drug abusers when athletes in most other sports were also using performance-enhancing drugs. ???Like anything else, it???s use and abuse,??? Cicherillo said. ???We???re the ones who are visual. We???re the ones who walk around, and you see us with the big muscles.???
Wheeler said he was convinced steroid use did not cause his kidney disease, although it might have made it worse.
The patient whose case was the centerpiece of the kidney study said he was most likely predisposed to develop the condition. ???The drugs weren???t the reason I got sick,??? said the man, who declined to be identified because his steroid use was illegal. After taking a year off from steroids and bodybuilding because of the kidney disease, the man, age 34, is returning to competition. His symptoms have worsened, a sacrifice he said he is willing to accept.
???It???s just really hard to walk away from it,??? he said. ???I know I can only do this until my early 40s, so I really want to give it my all now.???
