Are wide-grip dips a good chest exercise?
Are wide-grip dips a good chest exercise?
ARE WIDE-GRIP DIPS A GOOD CHEST EXERCISE? (NO, NOT REALLY)
Although dips have been a standard compound exercise in chest routines for decades, I want to explain today why they are, in fact, not that great of an exercise for building the pecs with maximum effectiveness.
Before I get started, I understand that many lifters (especially the more old school guys) will become defensive on this one. Yes, I know that Arnold did them, and before I get started, let me just say this...
- I am NOT saying that dips do not pack size onto the chest; all Im saying is that out of all the various pressing movements available to you, they are probably the least effective choice.
- I am NOT saying that you must eliminate dips from your routine altogether; all Im saying is that if you are going to perform them, they should be given lower priority than your other pressing exercises.
Okay, heres why, contrary to popular belief, dips are actually not that good of an exercise for chest development
Are Dips A Good Exercise For Chest? The Reality
As Ive covered before, the primary function of the pec muscle is horizontal adduction. In other words, its to bring your humerus (the upper arm) across the front of your torso.
If you take a look at the actual mechanics of a dipping exercise, youll see that, because your arms are locked into a fixed position, only a small amount of horizontal adduction occurs as you press yourself up.
Youll still be hitting your pecs to a certain degree, but because the movement is mostly a combination of shoulder flexion and elbow extension, its actually your front delts and triceps that do most of the work.
On top of this, the resistance is not even in line with the major portion of the chest throughout the exercise. Regardless of how you position yourself during a dip, the line of resistance goes straight through your front delts, further increasing the activation of those muscles in comparison to your pecs.
In addition to these two points, dips are also the most dangerous pressing exercise to perform from an injury prevention standpoint. Though this doesnt necessarily say anything about its actual effectiveness for building the chest, its certainly still important to consider.
The dip promotes both internal rotation of the humerus and scapular protraction, which puts your shoulder joint into an awkward position that is more conducive to injury.
Heavy dips performed over a long period of time can definitely take their toll, and trust me when I say that a shoulder injury is one of the very worst things that can happen to your bodybuilding program.
After over a decade of training people and interacting with an endless number of lifters, I cant even count how many eventually complain of shoulder pain while performing dips.
So, to put it simply, dips put the majority of the load onto your front delts and triceps rather than your chest, while increasing your risk for shoulder injury at the same time.
Now, I already know what many people are going to say
But Ive been doing dips for years and have great chest development and no injuries!
A few points to consider
First, its highly unlikely that dips are the only exercise youre performing for chest, and you probably have other presses and flyes in your routine as well. Just because you have good chest development and you perform dips does not necessarily mean its specifically the dips that have helped you make your gains.
Second, obviously not everyone who performs dips is going to get injured. The point is simply that they increase the chances of injury.
Third, my point here is not that dips wont build your chest, but rather that they are the least efficient choice when you consider everything that is available to you.
In my opinion, the bottom line is this
Dumbbell presses and barbell presses will stimulate your pecs more effectively (particularly dumbbell presses, which allow for greater horizontal adduction and a natural pressing arch), and are safer on your shoulder joints as well.
In terms of building your chest, dips really dont add anything that you wont get from a basic flat/incline/decline dumbbell press and/or a flat/incline/decline barbell press.
For that reason, I cant see any good reason to include them in your routine. Theyll simply give you weaker chest stimulation, and more shoulder joint stress. Why bother?
For complete chest development, 1-2 free weight pressing exercises in combination with a flye exercise is really all you need. My top picks would be the flat or decline dumbbell press and the high-to-low cable crossover for each of those movement patterns.
If you do decide to keep dips in your routine, thats totally up to you. But at the very least, put them last in your routine, otherwise youre simply pre-fatiguing your front delts and triceps prior to your other pressing movements. And on top of this, keep the weights moderate and make sure to use a controlled rep cadence coupled with perfect form at all times.
I did dips for years, but eventually eliminated them due to dual shoulder impingement. The dips alone didn't cause them, but I am certain they contributed and they certainly exacerbated the problem once it was present. I soon decided to keep them out of my routine permanently as I determined there were other exercises I could do that offered the same or greater benefits without the added stress on my joints.
Originally Posted by Prince
Originally Posted by Acheron
+1 In my younger days they were a staple, but due to shoulder impingement issues, I dont do them anymore.
By fqqs in forum Training
Last Post: 12-10-2011, 10:21 AM
By motionman04 in forum Training
Last Post: 12-06-2007, 07:34 AM
By spike in forum Training
Last Post: 09-03-2004, 09:07 PM
By Rocco32 in forum Training
Last Post: 12-08-2003, 04:53 PM
By swordfish in forum Training
Last Post: 10-13-2003, 05:59 PM