Barbell Curl vs. Dumbbell Curl: Why You Need Both For Maximum Gains

Results 1 to 2 of 2
  1. #1
    Purple One
    ADMINISTRATOR
    The Admin's Avatar


    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Gender
    Male
    Posts
    74,293

    Thanks Thanks Given 
    466
    Thanks Thanks Received 
    1,166
    Thanked in
    925 Posts
    Rep Points
    2147483647

    Barbell Curl vs. Dumbbell Curl: Why You Need Both For Maximum Gains

    Barbell Curl vs. Dumbbell Curl: Why You Need Both For Maximum Gains

    Let’s compare how the two can help you achieve your gains!

    The barbell and dumbbell curl are two variations which should be staples in your arm workout routine if aesthetic biceps are what you’re after (we’d hope so).

    They each have their own benefits and drawbacks but that’s the beauty of having multiple options… you don’t have to choose just one (and you definitely shouldn’t).

    But it is beneficial to know how each one can help you to maximize your bicep gains and so we decided to do a comprehensive comparison of the two. And we hope you can learn enough to utilize both training tools effectively.

    The Barbell Curl
    This bicep exercise variation is a bilateral (affecting both sides) movement and as a result, you can train using maximum loads since the weight lifted is equally distributed across both biceps (unlike the dumbbell variation which we’ll get to shortly).

    And you also don’t need as much balance and stabilization to perform this variation. But another benefit is that you can increase the weight in 2.5 lb increments on each side which you cannot do with a fixed dumbbell.

    And not too mention, training with a barbell is a must for strength athletes who compete, so functional carryover is imperative.

    Drawbacks
    • Limited movement options (e.g. supination, wrist position)
    • May result in the overuse of dominant side/not ideal for muscle imbalance
    • Can be harder on wrists

    The Dumbbell Curl
    This dumbbell curl, on the other hand, is a unilateral (affecting one side) movement which requires more balance and stability to effectively execute since there’s less support from the opposite side.

    Unilateral training has significant benefits for coordination, preventing muscle imbalance, core stability, rehabilitation purposes, plus it’s very necessary for functional performance and daily activities. (1)

    But an awesome benefit of dumbbell training, in general, is that there are more exercise options overall due to the unrestricted range of movement. And… they’re generally pretty portable too.

    Drawbacks

    Limited weight
    Harder to balance and control during heavier lifting
    5-pound weight increase which may compromise form and/or limit progressive overload.
    So, now that you know the difference between the two, let’s talk about what the research says about the effectiveness of each variation.

    Check out these 5 best ways to build better bicep peaks!

    What Research Says…
    One 2018 study which compared the barbell curl, EZ bar curl, and dumbbell curl found that the barbell curl and EZ bar curl resulted in similar EMG (electromyographic) activity for the biceps brachii and brachioradialis. (2)

    But the EZ bar curl was shown to have higher activation of the two muscles previously mentioned, out of the three exercises (only slightly more than the straight bar) because of the semi-prone wrist position.

    Unilateral training has significant benefits for coordination, preventing muscle imbalance, core stability, rehabilitation purposes, plus it’s very necessary for functional performance and daily activities. (1)

    But an awesome benefit of dumbbell training, in general, is that there are more exercise options overall due to the unrestricted range of movement. And… they’re generally pretty portable too.

    Drawbacks
    • Limited weight
    • Harder to balance and control during heavier lifting
    • 5-pound weight increase which may compromise form and/or limit progressive overload.

    So, now that you know the difference between the two, let’s talk about what the research says about the effectiveness of each variation.

    What Research Says…
    One 2018 study which compared the barbell curl, EZ bar curl, and dumbbell curl found that the barbell curl and EZ bar curl resulted in similar EMG (electromyographic) activity for the biceps brachii and brachioradialis. (2)

    But the EZ bar curl was shown to have higher activation of the two muscles previously mentioned, out of the three exercises (only slightly more than the straight bar) because of the semi-prone wrist position.

    And both the barbell curl and EZ bar were found to be superior to the dumbbell curl for activating these two muscles.

    However, one Ace-sponsored study tested several exercises using 16 participants to find out which ones were the best for activating the biceps through EMG activity.

    And the exercises included the concentration curl, cable curl, chin-up, barbell curl, EZ bar curl (wide and narrow grip), incline curl, and preacher curl.

    Well, what university researchers discovered was that the concentration curl was the superior movement, followed by the cable curl, chin-up… and then the barbell curl.

    But the likely explanation for this is that the concentration curl is more likely to result in better isolation of the biceps without as much involvement from the front deltoids or any other muscles.

    And the same study did find that anterior (front) deltoid involvement was higher in the barbell curl than the incline curl, chin-up, and concentration curl. But another possible reason for the higher EMG activity during the concentration could have likely been from mental concentration as well.

    Now, a concentration curl and a standing/sitting dumbbell curl could be considered as not the same exercise.

    But if comparing the bilateral movement of a barbell curl or any variation to a unilateral dumbbell curl variation, then this is very beneficial information for a comparison of the two.

    Also, these studies have not included all possible training variables and the results are based on general, overall muscle activity, not necessarily taking into account the potential benefits of utilizing various angles and training methods.

    So, based on these two studies and limited research which considers all factors, we’re convinced that doing a variety of bicep exercises is your best bet for not only achieving maximum muscle activation but for strength and function as well.

    So, that brings us to how we can maximize our training by utilizing different tactics and techniques…

    Get the best biceps contraction to stimulate more growth!

    How To Maximize The Barbell and Dumbbell Curl For Optimal Gains
    When it comes to maximizing the effectiveness of both the barbell and dumbbell curl variation/s, there are some things to avoid and some you want to make sure to include.

    Now, because there are options for various wrist positions, angles, and hand placement; we need to cover this aspect of bicep training to ensure we achieve the best possible outcome.

    But we do need to have some knowledge of the anatomy of the biceps and associated muscles as well; which will allow us to train according to how they are attached and how they function.

    Anatomy Lesson
    We probably don’t need to tell you where the bicep is located (on the front of the upper arms between the shoulder and forearm if you didn’t know) if you’ve ever taken a basic anatomy lesson.

    But the primary function of the biceps brachii (scientific name) is to flex the elbow joint which also pulls the forearm upward and rotates it outward. And it has two heads (long/outer head and short/inner head) which perform the same function.

    Both heads are attached at the shoulder joint and they join at the elbow. But the function at the elbow is more pronounced than the function at the shoulder. However, it’s still good to include both and we’ll discuss how to effectively achieve this a little later on…

    Now, underneath the bicep is the brachialis which primarily flexes the forearm at the elbow. This muscle gets worked during any variation of a bicep curl.

    And the brachioradialis is a muscle located in the forearm which starts at the lateral supracondylar ridge of the humerus, travels up the forearm, and inserts into the distal radius at the radial styloid process.

    Simple enough, right?

    Ok, let’s get back to discussing some of the various training variables which can affect muscle involvement during a curl variation…

    Training Variables
    Research shows that wrist position does in fact influence which muscles are primarily activated during a variation of a curl.

    One study compared the supinated, neutral, and pronated hand position for activation of the biceps and brachioradialis. And it was discovered that the brachioradialis muscle had a biomechanical advantage over the biceps when the wrist is in a pronated position. However, the biceps showed no significant muscle activation in any hand position.

    So, what this tells us is that if you want to maximally target the brachioradialis, then use a pronated hand position during any variation of a curl.

    But outside of the pronated wrist position targeting the brachioradialis, you cannot isolate either head of the bicep. However, you can emphasize each head using varying hand positions.

    A wide grip can emphasize muscle fibers of the short (inner) head while using a narrow grip can emphasize more of the long (outer) head. (3)

    So, it’s a good idea to use varying hand positions in order to squeeze out a little more stimulation, whereas using a neutral grip may not fully maximize each head.

    And remember when we told you that the bicep is attached at the shoulder joint and joins near the elbow? Well, to maximally train the biceps at both ends, you have to use proper technique conducive to optimal stimulation.

    Every bicep curl variation activates the bicep at the elbow joint but since the bicep crosses the shoulder joint, the slight elevation is necessary to maximally emphasize the fibers near the shoulder.

    So, let’s talk about effective barbell and dumbbell curl variations and then we’ll give some beneficial exercise tips…

    Barbell Curl Variations/Exercises
    There are many variations of the barbell curl (although not quite as much as with the dumbbell curl) and that’s good news because, like any exercise, it can get monotonous.

    So, options always keep your training fresh and exciting.

    Here are some great barbell curl variations…

    Standing EZ bar curl
    We’ve talked about the EZ bar curl and you definitely want it in your bicep workout routine. It alleviates a lot of wrist stress while showing high activation of the biceps and brachioradialis.

    But the great thing is, you can train very heavy without having to worry about the pain.

    Standing straight barbell curl
    This is pretty much the default barbell bicep curl. You can use massive loads to really overload the biceps and it’s a great overall movement. But if it bothers your wrists, refer to the EZ bar variation.

    Standing cable curl
    You can also do this one using a single grip which would be more of a unilateral movement like the dumbbell curl. But, we’re going to group it with the barbell exercises.

    Cables are an amazing training tool due to the constant tension on the target muscle and freer range of movement. Plus, in the Ace study mentioned previously, it was right up there at the top for bicep activation. (4)

    Barbell preacher curl
    The preacher curl is great because prevents cheating and you can really isolate the bicep muscle. Plus, your upper arm is slightly elevated which involves more of the bicep near the shoulder joint.

    So you definitely want to fit this movement somewhere in your regime.
    • Dumbbell Curl Variations/Exercises
    • Standing Dumbbell Curl
    • Standing Dumbbell Curl

    Dumbbells are awesome due to the versatility so there’s no shortage of exercises. But we’ll list a few of the top ones…

    Concentration curl
    Earlier we talked about how this exercise is superior to many other common variations. The key to doing it correctly though is to drop your elbow down so that your Tricep lies against your inner thigh.

    This will prevent you from rocking back during the movement. And just focus on a strong mind/muscle connection for maximum benefit.

    Standing alternating dumbbell curl
    This variation is undoubtedly the standard for dumbbell bicep exercises. It’s an excellent movement that allows you to train using maximum loads and you really get the unilateral benefits where total body function is concerned.

    Avoid cheating and using too much front deltoid and supinate at the top for maximum bicep contraction.

    Seated incline dumbbell curl
    The seated incline curl is a great exercise that really stretches the biceps and it’s a very effective movement which elicits considerable neuromuscular effort when performed through a full range of motion. (5)

    Standing dumbbell preacher/incline curl
    If you don’t have access to a standing preacher curl stand, then you can set up a bench to a high incline. And again, you’ll get a great stretch in the biceps and it’s a great variation for purely isolation.

    You can really focus on each bicep which is beneficial for developing a mind/muscle connection.

    These exercises are great for structuring your bicep routine around at first to keep things simple. They will improve your strength, build muscle, and help you to develop a good mind/muscle connection for a better contraction.

    Barbell and Dumbbell Curl Exercise Tips
    These tips are pretty much the same for both the barbell and dumbbell variations since a curl is a curl. But we’ll explain any differences which need to be acknowledged.

    1. Perform the curl in a semicircular (arc) motion to get full extension and contraction.
    2. Focus on the contraction and controlled negatives.
    3. Leave your ego at the door (lift what you can handle).
    4. After you reach just above the bottom portion of a curl, lift your upper arm forward about 30 degrees to activate the bicep near the shoulder joint.
    5. Avoid involving your lower body and back in a standing curl.
    6. Make sure to get good supination of the wrist and squeeze the biceps at the top.
    7. Lower the weight in a slow and controlled movement.
    8. Utilize various rep ranges (8-20 is ideal because the weight won’t be too light or heavy).
    9. Train to failure often to elicit a growth response.
    10. Use dumbbells to correct imbalances and avoid barbell work until you’ve improved.
    11. Cheat curls are beneficial once in a while and should not be performed using excessive rocking, but rather a little momentum.
    12. Use both for maximum gains!
    13. Sample Bicep Workout
    14. Make sure to warm up with a few lighter progressive sets before you attempt the working sets.


    EZ bar curl superset w/ seated incline curls
    3 sets x 10 reps to failure each exercise (30-second rest between sets)
    Up for an even more hardcore bicep challenge? Try These 7 exercises or do the full workout!

    Wrapping Up
    The barbell and bicep curl is the best free weight options that we have at our disposal for maximizing our fullest bicep potential.

    These exercises will pack on the size and strength while offering so many variations and interesting ways to include them in your arm routine.

    Both have advantages and drawbacks but so does everything in life. But weight training and fitness, in general, is really about using different tools to ultimately achieve one goal in the end.
    Attached Images Attached Images
    • File Type: jpg 1.jpg (50.7 KB, 5 views)
    • File Type: jpg 2.jpg (49.2 KB, 5 views)
    • File Type: jpg 3.jpg (50.1 KB, 5 views)
    • File Type: jpg 4.jpg (14.6 KB, 5 views)

  2. #2
    Newbie


    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    11

    Thanks Thanks Given 
    0
    Thanks Thanks Received 
    0
    Thanked in
    0 Posts
    Rep Points
    100

    Good information here.

Similar Threads

  1. curl bar? or barbell? or dumbbell?
    By TKD in forum Training
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 03-27-2007, 01:27 PM
  2. Barbell curl form
    By min0 lee in forum Training
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 03-04-2006, 02:57 PM
  3. One Arm Barbell Curl
    By tree in forum Training
    Replies: 42
    Last Post: 08-29-2005, 10:41 PM
  4. What exactly hurts after barbell curl?
    By Michael D in forum Training
    Replies: 38
    Last Post: 03-22-2004, 10:28 AM
  5. Standing Barbell or Preacher Curl?
    By Robert_ in forum Training
    Replies: 21
    Last Post: 11-13-2002, 10:15 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Copyright© 2001-2019 IronMag® Bodybuilding Discussion Forums