What was his reasoning behind 8-12 reps being better for strength training? It isn't, is the simple answer.

So my friend and I got in an argument about lifting today. He claimed that 8-12 reps is the best for building strength. I disagreed and said less reps and more weight is better for strength training.
Whose right?


What was his reasoning behind 8-12 reps being better for strength training? It isn't, is the simple answer.
http://www.getlifting.info
This may hurt a little... - Training Journal 2012
Disclaimer: All health, fitness, diet, nutrition, anabolic steroid & supplement information posted here is intended for educational and informational purposes only, and is not intended as a substitute for proper medical advice from a medical doctor. We do not condone the use of anabolic steroids (AAS), all information about AAS is for educational and entertainment purposes only. If you choose to use AAS it's your responsibility to know the laws of the country that you live in. Consult your physician or health care professional before performing any of the exercises, or following any diet, nutrition or supplement advice described on this website.

Strength training reps should be around 5 usually. 8-12 reps is not for strength training, but it's good for muscle building






* personally I have had success in the rep range of 6-10. when training with heavy loads at or above 80-85% of the 1RM reps 9-10 I usually hit using a rest-pause.
Tudor Bompa recommends the 1-6 (6 being the ultimate max) reps at loads around 80-85% of the 1RM. Below is some text from his book Maximum Strength Training Second Edition page 234.
"Training Methods and Duration for MxS"
Exercises for the developement of MxS must not be carried out under the conditions of exhaustion as in the H phase. During MxS training, the muscle should be allowed to recover maximally between sets. Due to it's maximum activation of the central nervous system, and the high levels of concentration and motivation it requires, MxS training improves the links with the CNS that lead to improved muscle coordination and synchronization. Strength depends not only on the size of the muscle and the total number of cross bridges, but also on the CNS's capacity to "drive" that muscle.
High activation of the CNS (i.e., muscle synchronization) also results in inhibition of the antagonistic muscles. When maximum force is applied, therefore, the antagonistic muscles are coordinated in such a way that they do not contract to oppose the movement-allowing the athlete to lift even heavier weights.
Last edited by LAM; 09-08-2010 at 09:50 PM.
I train differently than most, my beef is with gravity the weights on the bar are just the medium...Thanks to Wall Street your slice of the American Pie has been reduced to a crumb.


8-12 is great for training strength, but it depends on how it is factored into a complete program.

low reps/high weight = mass/strength, high reps/low weight = muscle definition. high reps/high weight = strength imo
6'4" / 265 lbs/36 yrs old.bench 365 incline 275, decline 335,leg ext. machine; entire stack
leg press 810lbs,sled 500lbs,seated dips 410lbs
chest press 400lbs,shrugs 450-500lbs
For building maximal strength, no.
For building strength endurance, yes.
There are a lot of components of strength. Louie Simmons is always talking about the 3-4 components of strength. I think 8-12 reps is fine for your assistance work but if you want maximal strength in a lift, you're going to have to lift maximal loads every once in awhile.
DISCLAIMER: