Citrulline Malate vs L-Citrulline
Two commonly seen forms of citrulline seen are citrulline malate and l-citrulline. So what’s the difference? L-citrulline is the non essential amino acid known to boost nitric oxide production in the body. Citrulline malate is the combination of l-citrulline with malic acid, which is believed to increase absorption rates and bioavailability. Now that we know what the difference between l-citrulline and citrulline malate is, let see how they work.Understanding How Citrulline Works
Studying the new research and data on this ingredient, there was something big that stood out that may be preventing athletes from getting the full benefit of supplementing citrulline. It deals with the dosage and timing of ingestion, which is something that is often vague or lacking on supplement labels. So to get the full benefit, it is important to know how much to ingest, and how long before training you need to ingest it. To best understand why the dose and time is important, we have to dig into a little biochemistry.Citrulline Malate is a dietary amino acid that plays a major role in proper circulatory function. It is also a major intermediary in the urea cycle. Citrulline works together with Arginine and Ornithine to recycle ammonia and in the effective production of nitric oxide. The breakdown of amino acids within the body results in ammonia as a byproduct. Since ammonia is toxic, the body converts the ammonia to urea in the liver, which travels through the blood and the kidneys filter it out of the body via urine.
The basic process of removing ammonia from the body happens like this:
- Ammonia converts to carbamoyl phosphate
- Carbamoyl phosphate reacts with ornithine, resulting in l-citrulline
- L-citrulline reacts with aspartate to form argininosuccinate
- Argininosuccinate breaks down into fumarate and arginine
- Arginine breaks down to form urea and ornithine
- Ornithine starts the process over by reacting with carbamoyl phosphate (ammonia)
Pros and Cons of Arginine
Since exercise up-regulates amino acid catabolism and thus the production of ammonia, it is easy to understand the initial rationale behind supplementing with these urea cycle amino acids, specifically arginine.Since arginine also converts to nitric oxide, it was thought to be the perfect supplement ingredient. Nitric oxide is a signaling molecule that quickly results in increased blood flow by vasodilation.
Increasing blood flow, especially during training and competition, means an increase in delivered oxygen and nutrients to working tissue and more efficient removal of metabolic waste. This is why arginine was, and still is, used as a pre-workout ingredient to “increase muscle pumps.”
“Arginine was, and still is, used as a pre-workout ingredient to ‘increase muscle pumps’. Unfortunately there were some unintended side-effects”
The issue with arginine supplementation, researchers discovered, is that the dose needed to increase plasma levels of arginine tends to be very difficult for the intestines to absorb, which results in gastrointestinal distress…also known as diarrhea. Researchers since have found out that supplemental citrulline, compared to supplemental arginine, results in elevated plasma levels of arginine for a longer period of time, without any gastrointestinal issues.
For general circulatory health, research therefore recommends 1000 mg of L-citrulline taken three times per day, but for improved sports performance, supplementing with 6-8 grams of citrulline malate seems to work the best.
So why not throw 6-8 grams of citrulline malate into your pre-workout mix, or buy a pre-workout product with that much citrulline? Well, most pre-workout products are designed to ingest 20-30 minutes before training, or during the warm-up.
Citrulline malate takes about an hour to convert to arginine and then nitric oxide; so taking it right before training may not deliver significant ergogenic assistance.
Citrulline Dosage and Timing
To get the full benefit of citrulline, you need to take it an hour before you start training.This means you will probably have to ingest the fully effective dose of citrulline malate about half an hour before you normally consume your pre-workout supplement. For this reason, citrulline is an awesome stand-alone product, and not something that you will get the most benefit from if it is pre-combined with other pre-workout ingredients.
If you are looking to increase your training volume by delaying fatigue, reducing muscle soreness, increasing growth hormone production, boosting immune function, and improving aerobic and anaerobic endurance, then taking the time to schedule your citrulline malate ingestion before your other pre-workout ingredients is well worth the effort and planning.
Conclusion
Like every other “effective” supplement ingredient, you have to know the effective dose as well as the effective timing of ingestion. Citrulline malate can be a very useful tool in your arsenal of performance and recovery enhancing instruments, but only if you are willing to use it the way science has shown it to be effective.There are quite a few ingredients out there that can be very helpful at increasing training volume or improving recovery, but that may not be convenient when it comes to the traditional timing of pre-workout nutrition. There are plenty of pre-workout products that contain citrulline, though rarely at an effective dose.
Even if the dosage is effective, the recommended timing of ingestion is rarely long enough before training to deliver maximal benefit. So it is not as simple as “does it work, or not?” It works, when you use this tool within the guidelines research has provided. Outside of the correct dosing and timing, though, citrulline is very much a waste of time and money.
