Yes, in the picture, in MY opinion, she looks fine...In YOUR opinion, she looks fine...In HER opinion, she wants to gain weight...
We have a client who looks very similar...I think she looks fine...A lot of people thinks she looks very fine...She models...But in HER mind, she wants to gain weight and doesn't like the way she looks...
How is this ANY different from ANY bodybuilder on this board who in my view is already big enough and really should not add another pound of muscle but who thinks he needs another 10 lbs? How is this different from a person who's at 10 percent body fat and looks great already but wants to get to 7%? It's up to the individual to decide how he or she wants to look. So she wants to be a little bigger...that's really her choice. I chose, just like others did, to give her advice that might help her reach that goal. You can do the same or not...it really doesn't matter. If you don't want to help...then don't. It's just the internet, it really doesn't matter.
But just because someone has a goal we may or may not agree with, just because someone is new and doesn't know their way around the forum and where to post things, doesn't necessarily make them a troll and unworthy of receiving help. Perhaps they are a troll... does it really matter? A few people spent a few minutes making suggestions. Actually, I've spent more time responding to you than originally spent responding to her.
I offered her suggestions, if she asks for more specifics from me, I'll continue to do so. If she doesn't then there is no need for me to reply more. Us discussing it has taken up more time than her three original posts and the original replies.