Well to be fair, it is bodybuilding not fuckability. And while we're at it is there some reason that its ok to reward growth gut in the guys? Jay's got one of the blockiest shapes up there and he's a repeat Mr O.
IMO competitors respond to what the judges reward. If they reward the extreme, they promote the extreme.
Agree 100% with the fuckability issue, however there comes a point where a chick shouldnt look like a dude. Some of these women are seriously outrageous, and I dont mean that in a good way.
As for Jay being an O winner-that's just retarded. I never liked his or Ronnie's block gut. Victor Martinez and Phil Heath are much better competitors in that aspect. Truth be told, I'm a fan to the 80s and 90s physiques, and the same with women.