Michael Vick is one of the most gifted athletes to ever play in the NFL. He is so gifted in fact, he literally put the whole team on his back and carried them to the playoffs. He's probably the worst example you could have come up with actually, and his winning percentage is still 10 percent less than McNabb's, with considerably less time played.
I've already conceded to the fact that passer rating isn't the best way to go about valuing a QB which is why I presented the other stats. Not quite sure why you're still bringing this up...
Of course there are
some shitty QB's with decent winning percentages, but they were on good teams with very different philosphies. Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson come to mind immidiately. They were asked not to lose games, allowing defense and a solid running attacks to win ballgames, opposed to what Andy Reid has asked of Donovan. There is just no arguing a QB's winning percentage when your offense passes almost 70% of the time!! Donovan has won 65% of the games he's started and was asked to carry most of the workload his entire career without anyone to even throw to for the bulk of it.
How people consider him overrated, and how you consider
that comparing apples to oranges I guess is too much for this dumbass to comprehend..
