American Idol II

[butterfly]

Simon told Carmen she had a good country voice and should replace that girl in the Dixie Chicks It was hilarious!

I agree, Julia has a great voice but no confidence in herself

I still think Kimberly Caldwell has an "I'm all that" attitude problem.

HATE Corey and Charles and I'm not crazy about Kimberly Locke (girl in turquoise dress) or Rickey either

I thought Josh was AMAZING!!!

My faves are:
Josh
Ruben
Trenyce
Clay
Julia
Carmen

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

My faves are..

Trenyce then Kimberly Caldwell then Ruben then Josh then Ricky.

I like Kimberly C's attitude!! I think its because Im exaclty the same way.

 

[butterfly]

I was stunned, too, that Vanessa got cut!!!

I really have no idea who will get the axe tonight

 

[butterfly]

Charles is gone!!!

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

i am totaly shocked that julia d got to stay

 

[butterfly]

Not me... she's got way more natural talent then Charles. She only lacks some confidence.

 

[Stacey]

I have been watching american Idol II this time, and EVERY epiosode, I'm Addicted!

I Do NOT like Kimberly Caldwell, she's annoying, her voice to ME sounds to deep & guyish, and shes a Camera hog...Meaning..last night when They performed Foot Loose, and The Dirty Dancing song she totally was all over the camera.. .whatever!!

I LIKE IN THIS ORDER:
Treynese,
JOSH
Ruben,
Julia,
Clay,
Carmen,
kimberly Locke

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

Kimbery C IS *SUPPOSED* to be a camera hog.. she is a STAR, and people need to be HUNGRY for the attention.. not AFRAID of it like Julia D

 

[butterfly]

Women totally see through Kimberly C's conceited attitude and that's why we don't like her. She's vain and yes she has talent but she should be humble and thankful for it... not shoving it in everyone's face.

I doubt she's getting many female votes and would be seriously shocked if she won.

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

why is it bad for a female to be conceited?

WHy should all females be humble?

ambition and drive put the likes of madonna and mariah carey out there in the pop market.

granted alot of females were intimidated and did not LIKE either

BUT

these two were very sucessful in theircareers.

I would rather see a confident star rather than a girl with a rags to riches stroy, who looks scared all the time each round.. hoping she makes it thru.. honestly.. Im sure julia d is a nice person, but she doenst have the confidence of a star.

she looks in her eyes like a dog who gets beaten all the time by her master.

 

[butterfly]

There is a difference between being conceited and being confident... she is both! A woman should know herself and what she's capable of and respect the gifts she's been given least they be taken away.

I myself am very strong-willed, independent, confident, and ambitious and being such I applaud all other women who have the same qualities.

While I may not agree with every choice Madonna has made... I greatly respect and admire her for her astounding accomplishments.

Yes, I think Kimberly C. has talent, she commands the stage as Paula says and she's beautiful. But IMO she needs to lose the "I'm IT and the only one that is IT" attitude because truth be told... there are dozens of girls out there who are WAY more talented... Kelly Clarkson being one.

BTW, I appreciate these debates with you!!! No name calling and we respect each other's right to have an opinion on the subject!!!

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

LOL u know why? We are both libras!! Thats why we can discuss thin passsionately with no feelings being hurt!



now, I think she might be judges a lil harshly becuase she jumps up in the front.. I notice it too.. like when charles sang his swan song, she jumped up and danced with him..

some might think she was trying to rub it in, or trying to steal the limelight

but I totally feel her on that.. she was just trying to show him that she cared.. that he was still part of the family.

I see alot of my own personality in her..

alot of people think *IM* cocky and confident.. .. and I just cant help it, its just me, u know?

I was totally rooting for julia in the beginning, but MAN she needs a big ole kick in the pants.. I think Kim C is even trying to reach out to her.. what do you think?

 

[Stacey]

I agree with you Butterfly!!!

 

[butterfly]

Actually, I'm a Cancer... a moon child! The month and day on the b-day thing in my profile has a gliche in it... thought Prince was going to fix that

I grew up debating issues with my father and 3 brothers, so as long as you don't make any personal attacks, I can debate pretty much anything without taking it personally.

I can't decide if Kimberly reaching out to Julia is sincere or for the cameras b/c she has to know how bad those first few episodes made her look. So far I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt though.

You going to see Kelly and Justin's movie??? I'm quite sure it'll be cheesy but I love them both and couldn't pass up the opportunity to see them perform.

I totally can see Kelly on Broadway!

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

yeah I can see Kelly on broadway, BUT I didnt see the first seqason. all I can judge is her songs.. and I think they are total snoozer.. i think her songs are so boring.. her voice is good, but I think her songs are boring..

I dont like Justin.. I he is weird.. he has a weird look in his eye.. wayyy too vanilla bubble ghum pop for my tastes.

What happened to Ryan Starr? can she sing? She is gorgeous!!!

why didnt she make it farther?

 

[Arnold]

Originally posted by butterfly
... there are dozens of girls out there who are WAY more talented... Kelly Clarkson being one.

speaking of Kelly Clarkson she better join this board before she starts fitting into Ruben's clothes!!!

 

[StrutDaRoosta]

hey, she's got the money! she can afford to eat good now!

 

[Arnold]

well, last night she looked like she had gained around 20lbs since I last saw her.

notice how both of her outfits were black?

 

[butterfly]

Originally posted by Prince
speaking of Kelly Clarkson she better join this board before she starts fitting into Ruben's clothes!!!

Ouch

You're so harsh!!!

 

[Stacey]

Man Prince that was Harsh..lol...but its TRUE!!!!!! Shes A Beautiful Girl though, and sometimes an extra 10 lbs on someone LookS good, and healthy!(which is what she looks like she gained, NOT 20..no way!) She's a Cutie!

Butterfly~~ I am sure the movie will be Kinda Gay~ But I do want to see it!!!! I LOVE THEM TWO!

 

[butterfly]

Since I had to work late Tuesday night Fade taped it for me... well I watched it again last night and I think Trenyc is my fave to win!

 

[Arnold]

Originally posted by Stacey
Man Prince that was Harsh..lol...but its TRUE!!!!!! Shes A Beautiful Girl though, and sometimes an extra 10 lbs on someone LookS good, and healthy!(which is what she looks like she gained, NOT 20..no way!) She's a Cutie!

Butterfly~~ I am sure the movie will be Kinda Gay~ But I do want to see it!!!! I LOVE THEM TWO!

she does not look "healthy", she looks FAT!

 

[butterfly]

Originally posted by Prince
she does not look "healthy", she looks FAT!

We are all entitled to our own opinion...

I'd rather see her 10lbs overweight then 10lbs underweight and be all wrathy looking. Hate stick girls!

 

[Stacey]

Thank you butterfly!!!!!

I know when I lose to much weight... I can look really gross in my face, and its just gross, and Kelly looked healthy...

Your right, I would rather her look like that than say ... courtney cox arquette or Jenifer aniston!!

 

[butterfly]

So let's play catch-up... I couldn't believe "Hercules" got sent home last week!!!

Who do you think is going home tonight???

starting top left: Josh, Ruben, Kimberly L, Carmen, Kimberly C, Trenyce, Clay

 

[butterfly]

I'm thinking either Carmen, Kimberly C, or Clay is going home...

 

[lina]

When is that on?

I'm planning on watching boring Bachelor tonight but hopefully something else is on so I can switch back and forth..

 

[Stacey]

Heya Lina~ Did you find it on last night??

I'm SOOOOOOOO GLAD KIMBERLY CALDWELL GOT KICKED OFF~!!! YEAH!!!

 

[butterfly]

I think Kim C's attitude got way better over the last few weeks but I just don't think she is as talented a singer as the rest of the folks left.

Right now I'm betting on either Ruben, Josh, or Trenyce to win.

 

[Stacey]

BUTTERFLY~ I totally agree.. Kim's additude did get A LOT better.. and She was really cool last night w/ what she said after she got booted!!

I bet Ruben wins!!!