Great thread
I've really enjoyed reading this thread, especially the discussion about the usefulness of the full body workout. I think it is a common misconception that full body workouts are only useful for beginners and one cannot get results from them after the first few months of training.
The best results that I've ever gotten have been with full body workouts - maybe my body is in a minority that just responds better to that form of training, or maybe the programs were just designed better - and whenever I do the customary splits I feel like I am falling prey to the anterior/shoulder overtraining that CP and pfunk commented on. (The next time I try a split, hopefully I'll be able to avoid that using the info on other threads

)
Anyway, today I worked out with a new program designed using advice from this thread about volume and exercise balance and selection (it also included a little more core training for basketball and more exercises w/fewer sets/exercise, umm, just for my personal enjoyment of variety

). The friend I trained with, who is in decent shape, was completely beat, and I was definitely feeling it like I haven't in a while...felt great though! So thanks for the great sticky, CP, and discussion, all.
A couple questions: CP (or anyone who knows), would you mind elaborating on the significance of alternating vertical push/pull with horizantal push/pull? (I can start another thread if you want, but I thought it was directly relevant here.) What I mean is, I've always thought, especially with the pulling movements, that they were basically just variations of "back exercises," so I didn't know that there was a need to distinguish between horizantal and vertical. I am guessing it just boils down to anatomy and creating proper muscle balance.
Finally, I am still getting used to the idea of thinking of exercises in terms of movements and not body parts; quite honestly this was a new concept to me before joining this forum. Could any of you direct me to some resources that elaborate on that - why it is superior, what concepts and studies are behind it, etc?
Thanks again, all.