Originally posted by vegepygmy
A theory should not be presented as true until it has been proven. Simons Levay???s study does not prove a genetic link to homosexuality. He was apparently unable to eliminate significant variables, such as confirming the sexual orientation of all of the autopsy subjects in his small sample group.
In London a study of the brains of black cab drivers revealed that they had abnormally large hippocampus. Was this a result of a genetic trait that left them with no choice but to become black cab drivers? Or was it a product of their environment?
If sexual orientation is genetic and not a matter of choice, why would identical twins have different sexual orientations? This question has not yet been adequately explained by the scientific community.
Like I stated, I had a problem with levay's work because he did not have good controls and there weren't enough subject matters. The same can be said for the black cab drivers, but it suggests we need to look further into why the differences exist.
To use the twin argument is fallacious. As for twins, we are finding out that epigenetic material is as important as inheritance of a gene in terms of psychiatric diseases and other physical diseases as it expresses itself . Other "physical diseases" don't have 100% accordance and expression between identical twins as well.
Remember, we do not have to isolated a gene to prove it is a biological phenomenom. We still have not isolated the gene for male pattern baldness!
A better example of the biological basis of homosexuality can be found with congenital adrenal hyperplasia.. Up to 40-60% of these women have bisexual or homosexual tendencies, suggesting that the in utero (the hormonal environment during gestation ) can and may play a role in sexual orientation.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=1438641&dopt=Abstract
http://www.boskydell.com/political/outlooks.htm
http://health.ftmaustralia.org/library/96/1200.pdf
general lecture in reproductive medicine on
CAH http://home.epix.net/~tcannon1/Physioweek9.htm
These women are exposed to high levels of testosterone during their time in the uterus, many times it is corrected early and medications suppress the overactive adrenal glands.
Last edited: