How do "you" judge a quarterback? Stats or championships

[purplerain]

Example: The question was put forth was, who was better Peyton or Eli? Mike and Mike both said that Peyton was by far better than his baby brother "JUST BECAUSE OF STATS". Peyton has better stats than his brother so that makes him better. Well Eli is 8 and 3 in the playoffs compared to Peyton being 9 and 10. And right now Peyton is sitting and Eli is playing.

 

[D-Lats]

A win is a win who cares how many passes thrown as long as you are on top in the end. Imo

 

[swollen]

Hang on...what? I thought a quarterback was a refund..

Nah, seriously, I don't think it all bout stats, it's how they play the game. If the colts ofensive line didn't help payton, he wouldn't have the stats he's got.

 

[hoyle21]

Peyton is miles better than Eli. The Colts won two games without him.

Eli is average Qb who has a great defense he can rely on. Much like Joe Flocco.