This guy's bulking. True, and i should have mentioned it, but i was more or less agreeing with point from the article that the other person posted.
It's hard to eat all of the extra lean protein calories without supplimentation from shakes.
Actually, it's VERY hard to get all the protein from whole foods. When i bulk i too use protein supps. (except i add EVolive oil to mine)
Even when cutting, I think that protein shakes (which are basically predigested proteins) are basic for proper post workout nutrition.
Here is where i dissaree with most....i find the necessity for rapid digesting whey with simple carbs to get an insulin and amino spike to be more of a supplements marketing ploy than it actually being a critical tool. For the conveniece of it while bulking or whatever, sure it can't hurt. But personally I just seemed to have never gotten any better benefit from consuming a whey and simple carb shake after a workout.....then i did from a steak/chicken or whatever, whole food meal. There are studies upon studies i'm sure to back up either side here (most of which are probably skewed studies or bias, thats a whole other topic there). But it would make more sense to me to eliminate protein powders while cutting, simply for the increase in metabolism from consuming whole foods. Eitherway, everyone's different.
VanessaNicole
(Oh, and as Stick says, fat free milk is perfect. You can add slenda and frozen berries, too when bulking.)