Arnie's left nu said:Do you think it could be the starting of arthritis?
It could be. If you joint is really achy it is possible. the only reason i saw possibly a small tear in the meniscus is becasue you said you knee gives out at times which is a prety big sign. If it was a fulll tear you would be in terrible pain. Small tears don't require surgery usually (if you have a conservative orthopedic). They do however require a small bit of PT and then you are on your own to deal with the pain factor when it hurts. That sucks about your Dr. That is the problem with free health care. American's bitch about having to pay for a health care plan but we get more specialized treatment that way. You ahve to deal with whatever you can get since that guy has to see everyone. You saying you play sports and lift, k=makes you a problem care for him.